Tuesday, 16 March 2010

Pope Pius VII and Napoleon. Turbulent Decade 1800 - 1810

(continued from previous post)

In 1800 when Pius VII was elected Pope, the Catholic Church in Europe was in decline.  In France the Church was disavowed and persecuted, with seminaries closed  and the faith dying through lack of new priests.  Austria, under the Emperor Francis II, with strong nationalist and Febronist sentiments, had little regard for Rome except when it suited..

                   EMPEROR FRANCIS II OF AUSTRIA

Spain, under King Charles IV, was also strongly nationalistic, with the Spanish ambassador at Rome wielding great power and influence.On the positive side, Napoleon Bonaparte favoured  the new Pope who had shown previously that he was prepared to work with him in the Cisalpine Republic, and of particular significance,  had also shown that he was no friend of the Emperor

                                                   
               KING CHARLES IV OF SPAIN (Goya)

Initially there was every indication  that Napoleon wanted peace with Rome and the re-establishment of the Catholic Church in France, as is shown by his speech of  June 5, 1800:-

                  “I regard you, who are the ministers of this (Catholic) religion, which is likewise my own, as my dearest friends; and I declare to you that I shall know how to punish in exemplary fashion, and with the most drastic penalties, and if necessary with death, as disturbers of the public peace and enemies of the public good, all those responsible for the slightest insult to your or my religion ……..  My express intention is that the Christian, Catholic and Roman Religion shall be maintained in her full vigour and in the complete possession of that free and public expression which it enjoyed at the time when I first set foot in this happy country.
    ‘Whatever changes, especially in regard to her discipline, occurred at the time when I was first in Italy did so in despite of me and against my will. Merely an agent of my government…….I could not then prevent all those disorders….. armed now with full power I am determined to put into operation all those measures which I know to be most timely and efficacious in defending and sustaining that same religion.
    ‘Modern philosophers have tried to persuade France that the Catholic religion is the implacable enemy of every democratic system and of every republican government. From this arose that fierce persecution which the French Republic launched against religion and her Ministers and from this were born all those errors of which that unhappy Nation found herself the victim so often for so many years.
    ‘No small part was played in these disorders by the diversity of opinions which at the time of the revolution prevailed in France, divided as she was into the various sects in the matter of Religion.
    ‘Experience has disillusioned the French and has convinced them that the Catholic Religion is the one which more than any other is suited to every kind of government and that in a special way it develops the principles and sustains the rights of a Democratic and Republican Government.
    ‘I too am a philosopher, and I know that in no society can a man be honest and just if he does not know whence he comes and where he is going. Reason is not sufficient to give him this light, without which every man is obliged to journey in the dark. The Catholic religion alone, with its infallibility, confronts man with his beginning and end.
    ‘No society can exist without morality. There can be no sound morality where religion does not exist…..
    ‘When I can meet the new Pope I hope I shall have the pleasure of removing all the obstacles which may still prevent an entire reconciliation between France and the Head of the Church.’  
   
                NAPOLEON AS FIRST CONSUL (Ingres)

  Such was the version of Napoleon’s remarks published at the time, not only in Italy but also in France, until it was subsequently banned there by Napoleon’s police. This positive statement of intent from Napoleon, which also included  proposals to restore the Papal States, and to restructure the hierarchy of the Church in France in accordance with the Pope’s wishes, seemed to augur well for the Church, and greatly  encouraged the new Pope.

Unfortunately such intentions were easier stated than done. In France there was considerable clerical opposition, with Foreign Minister, Talleyrand, an apostate Bishop, since married, who had consecrated the first Bishop of the Constitutional Church, together with  elements of the Constitutional hierarchy, ill-disposed to any settlement on Rome’s terms.  Additionally, there was opposition from ‘hard-line’ monarchists and supporters of the exiled Louis XVIII, who feared that any accord with Rome would strengthen the position of the new regime.  In Rome, there was considerable suspicion and doubt concerning Napoleon’s real intentions, although the majority of Cardinals, taking account of all the prevailing circumstances, were in favour of a Concordat.
                         
                      KING LOUIS XVIII OF FRANCE

 Proposals for the French Concordat were sent for signing from Paris to Rome, but  many of the conditions were unacceptable.  Matters dragged on and the Pope found himself  pressurised by the French. Whilst prepared to compromise on inessential matters, the Pope was not prepared to do so on matters  which could endanger the faith and compromise souls;  ‘in negotiating the Concordat, the restoration of the Faith in France was to be the sole consideration’;  but neither was the Church prepared to be brow-beaten by threats that failure to sign the agreement might result in the loss of what remained of its temporal power.
    As a result of this impasse, it was decided that the Pope’s Secretary, Cardinal Consalvi,  should travel to Paris to discuss with Bonaparte those matters on which agreement was proving impossible. On arrival, Consalvi found himself up against both Napoleon and Talleyrand. Negotiations were long and difficult, and after agreement had been reached, and he was about to sign the document, Consalvi realised that the original agreement had been substituted by an altered version. Needless to say he refused to sign, and only when the original was returned, did he do so. This attempted deceit by the French was to be repeated at a later date in similar circumstances, when the Italian Concordat was under negotiation.  A period of forty days had been allowed for the respective governments to ratify the terms, and Consalvi immediately returned to Rome.   The document was back in Paris, bearing the Pope’s signature, within thirty-seven days.
     The First Consul did not delay in signing the document, but then neither said nor did anything for a period of six months!  Bonaparte was not satisfied with the Concordat, for it failed to give him the control over the Church that he wanted, and he knew that it would be unpopular with important sections of opinion in France. To remedy this, and before proclaiming the Concordat, he published alongside it, in the same volume and under the same title, extra regulations which safeguarded the government’s interests. Whilst these regulations did not have the signature of the Pope, they appeared to all intents and purposes, as part of the Concordat, and as such, an integral part of the new religious settlement in France. Such were the infamous '77 Organic Articles'.
 
       CARDINAL CONSALVI (engraving after Lawrence)                                                                                                       
Effectively, the First Consul had abrogated to the State those powers over the Church which Consalvi and his team had been at such pains not to concede.  Rome accused Napoleon  of  acting in bad faith, but in France because the 'Organic Articles' were essentially Gallican and directed against ‘Roman pretensions’, against ultramontanism, they evinced considerable support.  In Rome, there was  real fear that Napoleon might put himself at the head of the French Church – in the manner of Henry VIII of England, and in fact, for political reasons, Napoleon had ‘intimated’ that this was a possibility.  In truth Napoleon did not want this and would not have seriously contemplated such a step. Nevertheless,  across the Channel, and across the centuries, the English Reformation still exerted its baleful influence.
     France now occupied  the Cisalpine Republic, and Napoleon  decided to draw up a new Concordat for Italy similar to  that of  France. This time, Pope PiusVII and Consalvi were not prepared to make any concessions, for unlike France where the Church was no longer the established Church and the Pope had little or no room for negotiation,  Italy was a Catholic kingdom with statutory laws based on the Church’s teaching.  Unbelievably, the Italian Vice President, Melzi,  attempted the same trick as had been tried in Paris,  with the  substitution of false documents for the original.  This time the Pope threatened to totally repudiate the Concordat unless Melzi withdrew his decree. Whilst this was being effected, the French Tribunate declared  Napoleon to be ‘Emperor of the French’ with hereditary title. This was soon followed  by a request from Napoleon to the Pope, to travel to Paris and attend his coronation.
 
    THE CORONATION OF EMPEROR  NAPOLEON                       

Napoleon crowned himself Emperor Napoleon I on 2 December, 1804, at Notre Dame de Paris and then crowned Joséphine as Empress. The story that he seized the crown out of the hands of Pope Pius VII during the ceremony—to avoid his subjugation to the authority of the pontiff—is almost certainly untrue, the coronation procedure having been agreed in advance.     After the ceremony the Pope remained in Paris for several weeks, moving freely about the Parisian streets, visiting the churches, distributing Communion and blessing the crowds. When he departed in April 1805, the streets were lined with men and women kneeling with their rosaries, awaiting the papal blessing. The Parisians were pleased to have their Pontiff and showed their pleasure, and this was a great consolation to the Holy Father.
     With the French Concordat, Napoleon had made few, if any, genuine concessions to the Church, and some in Rome who had opposed the Pope’s decision to attend the coronation,  accused the Pope of ‘losing his faith to save his throne’, comparing him with his predecessor Pope Pius VI,  who had ‘lost his throne to save his faith’. This harsh and unfair accusation was unjustified, for the Pope had acted in the best interests of the Church as he saw it, and he had high hopes that the planned Italian Concordat when agreed, would reflect the wisdom of his actions.
    Unfortunately this did not happen.  In characteristic fashion the proposed Italian Concordat was bulldozed into the Italian legislative arena, in much the same manner as the French Concordat was imposed on France, although on more generous terms to the Church, especially with regard to  financial support from the State. The terms were sufficiently favourable  to merit consideration by Rome, but when it was later announced that the French Civil Code would also be introduced, it was impossible for the Pope to accept, for this was sharply at variance with Catholic moral principles, and the civil law in Italy – especially with regard to the legalisation of divorce.Thus it was that the Church in northern Italy, in her political sovereignty, in her organisation, and in her administration, but also in moral matters in which Italians had always been subject to her law, saw herself gravely threatened. Relations between the papacy and Bonaparte were in terminal decline.
    Some of the French hierarchy blamed the Roman Curia for the subsequent conflict between the Pope and Napoleon, accusing Rome of being more concerned about temporal interests than the overall good of the Church, accepting in good faith Napoleon's submission that he was founding a great new Catholic empire, whose principal opponents were the Protestant English, the schismatic Russians, and the Mohammedans. At this stage Napoleon’s empire included France, Belgium, the Rhineland, and northern Italy, all primarily Catholic nations, and to Napoleon was given the credit for the restoration of the Church in France.   Rome however, considered that  Napoleon’s greatest victories had been won against the Catholic Empire of Austria, and that his much proclaimed 'protection' of the papacy was effectually becoming a spiritual as well as a temporal enslavement.
   
       FRENCH DRAGOONS AND GUIDE (Meissonier)

The end of 1805 found French troops occupying Ancona, with Napoleon engaged on several fronts – against the Austrians in Bavaria and Lombardy, and against the British navy in Naples, with a large Russian force backing up the Austrian army in Bavaria. In January 1806, having defeated the Austrians at Pressburg, Napoleon acquired Venice and her dependencies. The Pope had made known to Napoleon his opposition to the occupation of Ancona, but to no avail,  for this port was destined  to be used  as a base for the invasion of Naples. The Emperor was intent on controlling Italy, and with his brother Joseph Napoleon, as King of Naples, and his step-son Eugene, Viceroy in Northern Italy, it became apparent that Rome and the Papal States constituted an integral part of his intended empire. He thereupon seized control of a large area in the Papal States, and
 
                                EUROPE 1803

 by April 1808 much of this territory had been incorporated by edict into the Kingdom of Italy. French troops were occupying Rome, although the Pope was still in residence, and on May 17, 1809,  Napoleon decreed that all the Papal States were to become part of his Empire, and Rome was to become a ‘Free Imperial City’. The Pope was to be allowed to remain Bishop of Rome, in possession of his palaces and with an appropriate revenue, but holding no temporal power.
     The immediate response of PopePius VII was to sign the Bull of Excommunication against all those responsible in any way for the sacrilegious seizure of the city. Events snowballed, with Napoleon determined to tolerate no resistance - even to the extent of ordering the arrest of the Pope, if absolutely necessary for the preservation of order. Thus it was in 1809, that a troop of French soldiers under General Radet, infiltrated their way into the Quirinal, where the Pope resided, and burst into a room wherein sat the Pope, five cardinals and several other prelates. The Pope dismissed the suggestion that he renounce all temporal sovereignty, ‘We cannot renounce what does not belong to us--'. He was given half an hour to prepare himself for a journey, and accompanied  by Cardinal Pacca, with only the clothes  they were wearing,  they were  bundled into a horse drawn carriage, which was then locked and driven out of the city along the road for Florence, with Radet mounted on guard in front. Subsequently Napoleon was to strongly criticise Radet for his arbitary action in arresting the Pope, denying any prior knowledge or authorisation.
   

                             POPE PIUS VII

It was little more than eleven years since Pius VI had been unceremoniously bundled out of Rome by the French, never to return, and Pius VII,  now also a prisoner of the French, assumed that a similar fate awaited him.     
(to be continued)

Grateful acknowledgement to 'Revolution and Papacy' by E.Hales,
published by Hanover House 1960.

Friday, 12 February 2010

Pope Pius VII, Napoleon Bonaparte, and the Austrian Empire (continuation)

 This post is a continuation of the previous post on  Pope Pius VII and the times and struggle of the Papacy in the aftermath of the French Revolution. It is important to consider the events in the late 1790’s involving Napoleon Bonaparte, the Austrian Empire, and Cardinal Bishop Chiaramonti of Imola, which events were to have such a profound influence on the subsequent  thinking and  actions of Cardinal Chiaramonti, in his capacity as  Pope Pius VII.

'Saint Michael the Archangel's Defeat of Satan' - by Guido Reni (1636)

 I am indebted to the book ‘Revolution and Papacy – the papacy and the revolutionary movement in Europe 1769 – 1846’ by E.E.Y.Hales, published by Hanover House 1960’, which has proved an indispensible source for the material in this post, and from which I have quoted.  For readability, clarity of thought and explanation, I cannot recommend this book highly enough.

(Continued from previous Post)

                 ‘In 1797 Napoleon defeated the Austrians at Rivoli, which resulted in  the Treaty of Tolentino - naturally on his terms, which included the surrender of the Legations - the most valuable and prized of the Papal States; a payment of fifteen million crowns;  and the seizure of valuable works of art.  Bonaparte decided against marching into Rome, primarily for military reasons, but also  preferring to keep the Church ‘on his side’ as it were, rather than aiming at its destruction - as the ‘Directeurs’ in Paris would have preferred. Similarly in his attitude to the Papal States, his interests were practical and military, he wanted the Legations for geographic, economic, and political reasons, for his plan was  the creation of a new Republic in which he would control the papal ports of Ancona on the east coast and Civita Vechia on the west coast,  with the geography of these States providing a natural defence against future Austrian invasion, and the rich productivity of the plains and the area generally, providing great economic benefits.
   
         Napoleon at the battle of Rivoli 1797 - followed by the Treaty of Tolentino.

 Although Napoleon was imbued with Republican sentiments, he had been brought up as a Catholic and he knew that although the Church might be temporally weak and disorganised, and sometimes wracked with spiritual division e.g. Jansenism, it was nevertheless tenacious, as the lesson of the Vendee had shown, and he had found Italy saturated in the Faith. From the beginning his policy wherever possible was one of appeasement, for to him it made no sense to oppose the Catholic religion. At Tolentino, he had told the Cardinal Archbishop of Ferrara, Mathieu, that, “if only they could see things aright at Rome, they would realise that I am no ogre but really their friend.” He also noted that during the fighting and disturbances, the Cardinal Bishop of Imola, Chiaramonti, the future Pope Pius VII, had remained at his post and cooperated with the revolutionary authority of the recently created Cisalpine Republic. Thus in this small but important experimental State, with its 3.5 million inhabitants, Catholic in tradition, we see Napoleon as a civil ruler, confronting the Church led by three Cardinals, viz. Archbishops of Ferrara, Bologna, and Imola. The first two Archbishops fought the new regime at every step, Chiaramonti  on the other hand, cooperated with it. Whereas his brother Cardinals at Ferrara and Bologna declared the secularist and egalitarian constitution of the Cisalpine Republic to be incompatible with the rights of the Catholic Church, Chiaramonti accepted that constitution,  and tried as it were, to ‘baptise’ it. It was his way, for when Bonaparte had first invaded Lombardy the previous year, and Chiaramonti’s diocese had fallen under the French, the Cardinal had told his flock to accept the new order, and had tried to dissuade those who had staged a futile revolt against it. For this he had been called a Jacobin ( a Revolutionary sympathiser), when his true objectives were calm, order, and mercy, as he showed when he pleaded with the  French General Augereau for the lives of the captured leaders of the revolt who had ignored his advice. When the constitution of the Cisalpine Republic abolished all titles and privileges, he was ready to give up his estates, to abandon his title of Monsignor, and to style himself ‘citizen Cardinal’. He saw that these things did not matter, what mattered was to save the essentials. Moreover he thought that the principles of the Revolution could be interpreted in a Christian sense. In his view the Church could have no quarrel with political liberty or with social equality; but for fraternity i.e. for the ideal of society held together only by the bond of natural human affection - he preferred to substitute the peace of God, or the bond which arose from being His children. He illustrated this interpretation by labelling his personal note-paper with ‘Liberty’on the left-hand corner, and ‘Equality’ on the right, only insisting on putting in the centre not ‘Fraternity’, but, ‘And Peace in Our Lord Jesus Christ’.

             

              Map of Europe showing part of Italy, including Papal States and Cisalpine Republic (1803)

 In practice there were only two occasions when the Cardinal had difficulty in collaborating with the French. The first was when they tried to introduce into Italy something analogous to the Civil Constitution of the Clergy, excluding the Pope from his canonical investiture of the Bishops and from all other rights in the Cisalpine Church, and introducing election of parish priests. The Cardinal succeeded in thwarting this by a mixture of flattery and firmness, when he responded to the Directors of the Cisalpine that ‘as perceptive men professing themselves solicitous for the dogmas and discipline of the Catholic Church, you would be sure to appreciate that her reorganisation must rest with her own ecclesiastical hierarchy’.  The second occasion was rather more difficult, arising as a result of the government deciding to adopt the French Declaration of the ‘Rights of Man’, proclaiming official ‘religious indifference’ on the part of the State; disestablishing the Catholic Church;  placing every sect, Christian, non-Christian, and anti-Christian, on a footing of absolute equality. In December 1797 the Cardinal was required to publish a Pastoral letter which would show that ‘the spirit of the gospel is founded on the maxims of Liberty, Equality, and .Fraternity, and is in no wise contrary to Democracy.’ Chiaramonti in a Christmas homily, set himself to show that, if only they were properly understood and interpreted in a Christian sense, there was nothing irreconcilable between the new revolutionary ideas and those of the Church. He insisted however, that the new ideas could only be carried out effectively if they were interpreted in a Christian sense. He had been told to demonstrate that the gospel was founded upon the maxims of liberty, equality, and fraternity, and was in no way contrary to democracy;  very well he would invert the demand and show that liberty, equality, fraternity, and democracy could only be founded on Christianity. He took his argument even further by showing that of all kinds of society, a democratic one was the kind which stood most urgently in need of the supernatural graces of the Church. For under the ‘old regime’, he pointed out, a man had been obliged to obey the government blindly, whereas in a republican democracy a higher degree of virtue was called for on the part of the citizen. Precisely because of this new responsibility, supernatural grace and the guidance of the Church were more necessary than ever. In other words the Revolution, far from superseding the Church, had made her more necessary than ever   “Ordinary virtue might, perhaps suffice to guarantee the lasting prosperity of other forms of government.  Our form requires something more.  Strive to attain to the full height of virtue, and you will be true democrats. Fulfil faithfully the precepts of the  gospel, and you will be the joy of the Republic.Be good Catholics and you will be good democrats”.
                 This homily, published by the future Pius VII, has some claim to be regarded as one of the key documents of modern Catholic history.  For in the 18th century the assumptions of Bossuet, who had taken it for granted that monarchical government was of divine right, had held sway amongst orthodox Catholics. It is true that the constitutional bishops in France had also accepted the ‘principles of 1789’, but then they had gone too far and lost sight of the unity and authority necessary to the Church.  Chiaramonti, abandoning inessential externals, and turning a blind eye towards the endless insults of the revolutionaries, accepted their political and social democracy, but at the same time affirmed absolutely and unequivocally, the essential need of the supernatural grace and spiritual guidance of which the Church was the custodian, and therefore the need for her to be independent in her organisation and spiritual authority. He foreshadowed the line of liberal Catholic thought in the nineteenth century - ‘The more one is a democrat the more it is necessary to be a Christian; the fervent and practical cult of ‘God-made-Man’  is the indispensable counter-weight of that perpetual tendency of democracy, to establish the cult of man believing himself to be God.’ (Montalembert, Malines Congress 1863). The bearing of Chiaramonti at Imola under the Revolution, was to prove the inspiration of a later Bishop of Imola, who would also be elected Pope, and who would take the name of Pius in honour of his predecessor. Pius IX in his early years as the ‘liberal Pope’ was inspired by the sympathies of Chiaramonti, just as later in the time of his troubles, he would repeat the very words used by Pius VII in his afflictions.     
                                
           Coat of Arms French Monarchy - Bonaparte Dynasty

Whilst the Revolution when it chose to, could harmonise its principles with those of the Church, and greatly benefit by so doing, it could not harmonise itself with Rome, for the Pope was not only Head of the Church but was also a temporal sovereign with a principality and a Court. The execution of King Louis XVI followed by that of Marie Antoinette, alienated any sympathy the Pope and the majority of Romans, might have shown for  the new regime. Thus in 1798 when the French, under General Berthier, invaded Rome, they found the Roman populace hostile, in spite of existing social and economic depression, and an elderly and sick Pope Pius VI with a papal government powerless  both to protect and to provide for its citizens. Once in Rome General Berthier declared the Pope deposed, and accepted an ‘Act of the Sovereign People’, setting up a consular regime, the document having been hastily drawn up by a scratch gathering of patriots that same morning.  The cardinals in Rome at the time, there to celebrate the twenty-third anniversary of the Pope’s election, were promptly arrested and imprisoned. The Pope was told that he had to leave within three days, after which he was taken first to Sienna, then to Certosa, outside Florence. He was 81 years old, physically and mentally exhausted, forced to move across the Appenines to Bologna, and thence to Parma. Then as the Austro-Russian forces encroached, he was moved yet again, first to Piedmont, then over the Alps to Briancon, Grenoble, and finally Valence, where he died in the dilapidated ‘Hotel du Gouvernement’, with a last prayer for his enemies. Pius VI had reigned for 24 years and 6 months, the longest pontificate since the traditional 25 years of St Peter. Although in some ways a worldly man, happiest perhaps among the treasures of his library and museum, or when watching the progress made in the draining of the Pontine marshes – an undertaking dear to his heart, he nevertheless had understood very clearly what was essential to the Church and what was the nature of the challenge, in his times, to her position; and there had never been any danger that he would yield on essential issues.  An aristocrat, he equally abhorred the French Revolution with its secularism and impiety, and the erastianism of the Austrian Emperor Joseph II. His death marked the end of an era, after the French Revolution and after the Italian revolutions, neither society nor the Church-in-society could be the same again. It was widely supposed that the Papacy itself had come to an end, although that had been supposed before and would be supposed again – notably in 1870. But in 1799, when the paralysed pontiff died in  Valence, and the cardinals were scattered, and the intellectuals were still talking about the new age of philosophy and reason, it did seem as though there might be something in it.
 
                    Austrian Empire - Coat of Arms (1804-67)

By the summer of 1799 the French forces had been driven out of Italy, and were in retreat on the Rhine, and its best general had left his army cut off in Egypt. Austrian forces occupied the Legations of the Papal States, and Rome was now occupied by Neapolitan troops.At the head of the anti-French coalition stood Emperor Francis II and his Chancellor Thugut. To them the Catholic Church represented both a natural and spiritual ally for everything for which they fought.  After all that had occurred in the last three years in Italy, it hardly seemed possible to them that the dignitaries of the Church should think otherwise. The Revolution was clearly ‘anti-Christ’; the Emperor was clearly ‘Defender of the Faith’ They were happy for the conclave to elect a new Pope, to be held in Venice, for true to the Josephist tradition they anticipated the election of a compliant Pope. Thugut saw this as an opportunity to secure the election of a friendly Pope who would be willing to yield to the Austrian protector of the Italian peninsular what was necessary to make that protection effective, namely suzerainty over the legations of the Papal States. Now that Austrian military power was paramount, he planned an Austrian protective belt across northern Italy which would prevent any further incursions by the French. In this plan, the Papal legations were important both militarily and economically, as had been recognised earlier by Bonaparte when he created the short-lived Cisalpine Republic. Unfortunately for Thugut, the cardinals knew what he wanted and why he wanted it, and they did not mean to let him have it. 

                             
        Francis II,  Holy Roman Emperor (1792-1806) and Emperor of Austria (1804-1835) 

The legations were not only the most prosperous part of the Papal States, without which the rest was unviable, but also the whole plain was peculiarly rich in Roman and Papal tradition, with the last four Popes  all coming from that region, or from neighbouring Venetia. When the Emperor argued that the legations had been signed away to Bonaparte at Tolentino in 1797 so why could they not now be transferred to the Emperor to help him defend the Roman religion, the response was that Tolentino had recognised a military ‘fait accompli’ in time of war, it had not given papal blessing to a new order in time of peace.
   
                                        
                             Coat of Arms of Pope Pius VII

  The Austrian government meant to change this Roman attitude, and they hoped that the election to the papacy of a suitably disposed Cardinal, would effect this. If the issue behind the Conclave of 1769 had been the fate of the Jesuits, the issue behind that of 1799 was little less than the ending of the temporal power of the papacy, for nobody supposed that the Papal States could long survive without the legations. In hindsight it could be argued that the ending of the temporal power and interests of Rome might not have been such a bad thing in so far as the Church would then have been able to concentrate its energies on its spiritual mission and role in the world. On the other hand, without a state and with northern Italy under Austrian rule, Rome would in fact, have been subject to Vienna. Thus with the papacy  retaining its temporal power, and with the Austrian army a comfortable 200 miles to the north –which was the situation after 1815, she could at least feel free from immediate domination by either Austria or France, with their intense mutual rivalry ensuring that neither would allow the other to make any strategic move in Italy. When in 1860/70 the Papal States were eventually eliminated, the new power which took their place was not strong enough to defy Catholic Europe and to oppress the papacy with impunity, as Francis II, who inherited the Josephist tradition, might well have done had he been sole overlord of Rome, and as Bonaparte soon did when he acquired that position, albeit for a retively short period of time.
 
         
            Monastic Church of San Giorgio,Venice - venue of Papal Enthronement of Pope Pius VII (1800)

Thus the Papal Conclave in Venice was critical.  We know from the numerous accounts of the Conclave contained in biographies and Church histories, that the candidate favoured by the Emperor was Cardinal Mattei, and the thirty-four Cardinals in attendance were fully aware of this. A stalemate ensued with some 18/20 cardinals supporting Cardinal Bellisomi, and 10 supporting Mattei. This deadlock continued for several weeks, when finally a third candidate acceptable to both sides was proposed. This was Chiaramonti, the Benedictine Bishop of Imola, who combined the qualities of holiness, simplicity, graciousness and humour. Only two tenable objections could be raised against him, the first that at fifty-eight years old he was too young, and the second that he was very close to the previous Pope who had reigned for more than twenty-four years, and the cardinals were tired of the friends and relations of the Braschi family. Neither objection was considered important, and Chiaramonti was duly elected,  taking the name of Pius VII out of deep respect for and in honour of  his predecessor.  Vienna was not pleased, and as we have already seen refused the use of St Mark’s for the papal enthronement, as well as immediately pressurising the new Pope with strident but fruitless demands for the outright cession to Austria of the three legations.   The new Pope having been enthroned in the monastic Church of San Giorgio, was refused permission by the Emperor to travel to Rome overland, and instead was forced to endure a twelve- day trip by sea in an ill-equipped and ill-manned frigate ‘la Bellone’, only to find on his arrival in Rome, that with the French victory over the Austrians at Marengo, the balance of power in Europe had changed yet again.


                                  The Battle of Marengo 1800

The papacy was once more confronted by Bonaparte...................
                                                                                                                                                                                              (to be continued)

Thursday, 21 January 2010

Pope Pius VII - Holy, Courageous, and Humble Pope


Some weeks ago I viewed an online auction which included an oil painting of Pope Pius VII. The portrait revealed the Holy Father in his late 50’s, with a thick, untidy mop of  black hair, very Italian - looking, with a long face, strong features and pronounced aquiline nose. The eyes were dark as were the bushy eyebrows, and the expression was alert and thoughtful. It was a striking portrait, and I found myself reflecting that I knew absolutely nothing about Pope Pius VII, and decided there and then to remedy this  regrettable state of affairs. I was able to borrow two books from the library of the Sons of the Most Holy Redeemer (F.SS.R),  courtesy of Fr Michael Mary.F.SS.R., both  dealing with the pontificate of Pope Pius VII (1800-1823).  What I have learnt from these books has really opened my eyes to the virtually insuperable difficulties and sufferings, spiritual, physical and temporal, of Pope Pius VII and indeed most if not all of the  Popes, since the French Revolution. The two books in question are ‘Revolution and Papacy- The papacy and the revolutionary movement in Europe, 1769-1846’ by E.E.Y. Hales, published by Hanover House  (1960);  and ‘Pope Pius VII – 1800-1823.   His Life, Times and Struggle with Napoleon in the Aftermath of the French Revolution’ by Robin Anderson, published by Tan Books (2001).




                                          POPE PIUS VII  (1800 -23)



Last year (2009)  was the 200th anniversary of Rome being declared a ‘free imperial city’ by Napoleon Bonaparte, Emperor of France, who then incorporated the Papal States into his empire. Pope Pius VII  published a ‘Bull of Excommunication’ of all concerned, whereupon he was arrested and taken  from Rome to Savona where he was imprisoned. The following year he refused to recognise Napoleon’s remarriage with Marie-Louise of Austria.
     It seems incredible to me, that these events occurred only 200 years ago, which somehow does not seem a very long time; even though the world has since experienced  two major World Wars and innumerable lesser wars, man has been to the Moon, technology has progressed to an extent undreamt of even 50 years ago, man’s knowledge of the natural world in the fields of medicine and the environment has made huge advances, the list is endless; yet 200 years  still does not seem that long!  There is one exception to this accelerating, almost frenetic, pattern of so-called ‘human progress’,and this is the unchanging dogmatic truth inherent in the Catholic faith. This will never change because Jesus Christ promised, when he made Peter the head of His Church, that He would be with the Church all days even unto the end of the world, and the gates of hell would not prevail against it. Of course there have been superficial changes, some more important than others, inevitable because the Church  cannot stagnate in the world, and it is made up of men and women influenced by, and members of, the society in which they live. 
  

       This is an absolutely inadequate and brief consideration of  the religious and political situation prevailing in Europe at the time of, and immediately following, the advent of the French Revolution, with some emphasis on the pontificate of Pope Pius VII. Any efforts of mine will be as a ‘drop in the ocean’ in the overall saga. I have quoted extracts from both books referred to above, and strongly recommend them to those wishing to increase their knowledge of this perhaps rather neglected, but absolutely pivotal period of Church history. Both are eminently readable, clear and concise, and authoritative in their content.


                            **********************
  


                                       POPE PIUS VI (1775-99)



‘The conclave had dragged on for nearly four months in the 
Venetian island ‘Abbey of St George’ (San Georgio), where, because of political conditions in Rome and Europe,  the electing cardinals had assembled on the death of Pope Pius VI.  On March 15th, 1800, the Benedictine Cardinal Gregory Barnabas Chiaramonti,  accepted election, and out of gratitude to his predecessor and benefactor, took the name of Pius VII.
    Venice was then governed by Austria whose rulers, members of the house of Hapsburg, had from medieval times held the title of Holy Roman Emperor. The Emperor, Francis II was disappointed with the result of the papal election as he knew that the new Pope would not favour his interests. As a result he refused permission for the coronation ceremony to be held in St Mark’s Basilica, neither would he allow the new Pope to pass through the Papal States on his journey to Rome, forcing him to travel by sea in a dilapidated, badly equipped old boat, escorted by the Emperor’s envoy.
    By the time Pope Pius VII reached Rome at the beginning of July, the French General Napoleon Bonaparte’s victory over the Austrian forces at Marengo, had  significantly altered the European balance of power. The Pope was no longer fettered by the Emperor Francis, instead he was confronted by Napoleon, the ‘First Consul’ of  France, who in 1804 was to become ‘Emperor of the French’ and overlord of most of Europe.
    Napoleon’s fifteen year rule (1799-1814) was to prove a decidedly mixed blessing for France and for the Church. A man of military genius and great energy, he restored order after the chaos and bloodshed of the French Revolution of 1789, although he was himself imbued to some extent, with the tenets of the Revolution. His political ambitions further caused him to contest the sacred rights of the Pope and the Church, rights which he endeavoured to dominate and use for ruling and extending his empire.
 


                                     NAPOLEON BONAPARTE
                                    'Emperor of the French' (1804-13)


The death of Pope Pius VI in France in August 1799, a prisoner of the French revolutionaries, had left the Catholic Church in an apparently catastrophic plight. The Pope was mockingly called ‘Pius VI the Last’, and many thought, not for the first time, that the papacy was finished.
    During the latter part of the 18th century the philosophy of Kant in Germany and Hobbes in England discarded the concept of ‘supernatural faith’ in divine revelation, and led the way to the so-called  ‘Illuminism’ of the French philosophers who purported to propagate modern science and culture. The ‘Age of Reason’ was proclaimed: ‘mankind, previously in its infancy, had now at last reached maturity.’
The writings of Rousseau and Voltaire had popularised ideas of man’s natural goodness, with no need for authority and law in Church or society. In 1786 the Illuminatist society, secretly founded in Bavaria with anarchical aims, was banned.  Its founder, Weishaupt, fled to France, where he merged the society with Freemasonry. The way was paved for revolution.
    Any means were considered permissible for overthrowing monarchy and lawful government, and for abolishing private property, hereditary rights, patriotism and military obedience, the family and marriage. With great cunning, Illuminatism appeared to be serving cultural and social interests, whilst pursuing its secret ends. Members included Robespierre, Mirabeau, the Duke of Orleans (who provided the money), and the half-mad Cagliostro, hater of priests and kings, and others who were to become leading protagonists of the French Revolution.

    On the religious front, Jansenism, originating with Jansenius, Bishop of Ypres (1585-1638) and possibly one of the most formidable heresies ever in the Church, was strongly established in Europe and spreading.  Hostile to Rome and papal authority, and thus inevitably to the Jesuits, it challenged the Church’s magisterium and power of jurisdiction, but hid its true nature under various reforming ideals. Although the 101 censures of the Papal Bull ‘Unigenitus’ (1713)  proclaimed by Pope Clement XI, condemned almost every known Jansenist tenet,  the authority of Rome was insufficient in France to prevent Jansenist ideas being taught in seminaries or even approved by some Bishops. Jansenists called for a return to what they regarded as the ‘attitude of the Early Church’- based on the Christian church of the first six centuries, and they welcomed persecution as a sign that they were right. They only regarded  the earlier Councils of the Church  as valid; the later aggrandisement of  Papal power, the Lateran Councils, the Council of Trent, and worst of all the Jesuits, represented something alien. They preached an ‘Elect’ - viz. themselves, and by exaggerating the teaching of St Augustine on the power and necessity of God’s grace for any efficacious act, and man’s helplessness either to gain it or to act aright without it, they made themselves not only into an Elect, but into a pre-destinate Elect, like the Calvinists.  Jansenists  differentiated between the ‘Holy See’ and ‘Rome’. For the former they expressed respect (in principle), but for the latter, the Rome of ‘Unigenitus’ and still worse, the Rome of the Jesuits, they had only hatred.
They were enamoured of their own ‘idea’ of the Church, in complete contrast to the Jesuits who served the Popes of the day, with no special significance attached to the early Church. For them there was one Church, divinely established, which included saints and sinners, tares and wheat, foolish virgins and wise, and in that Church the supreme authority was the Pope. Only he – with or without the aid of a General Council- could define dogma. And as for pious practices, new rules for life in communities, special devotions, and the like, the Society of Jesus accepted them as elements in the developing life of the Church, but only to be embraced as orthodox, and recommended to the general use of Christians, if they received the sanction of Rome.
   

                                POPE CLEMENT XI (1700-21)
                Issued Bull 'Unigenitus' 1713 condemning Jansenism



The Jansenists,  rebuffed by Rome, but ever seeking more support, cultivated  many friends among the lower clergy, proposing that they had a right to share in the government of the Church. This idea was based on the flattering theory that if Bishops were the descendants of the twelve apostles, it followed that the parish priests were the descendants of the seventy-two disciples, sent out by Our Lord; and they were therefore entitled to their voice in the defining of dogma and in serious disciplinary measures such as excommunication. An ever-widening gulf existed between the influence and condition of life of the lower clergy and those of the higher. As a class they had become depressed by the gradual elimination of the local patron and by the increasing control over the avenues of patronage and promotion enjoyed by the bishop. The parish priest had discovered that in order to secure his advancement, he must at all cost please his ecclesiastical superiors.
     But if the priest must please his bishop, the bishop must please his king. Bishops were nominated by the king or ruler, and throughout the electorates, grand-duchies, and principalities of Europe, it had become customary by the year 1769, for Rome to approve the choice of the ruler. It was this custom which lay at the root of those essentially secular loyalties amongst the higher clergy, which in France showed themselves in Gallicanism;   in Germany – Febronianism;   and in Austria – Josephism;   three terms which described, in different contexts, a closer association between Church and State, which to greater or lesser degree, was widely accepted by the ecclesiastical hierarchies. The opposite tendency, ie  the acceptance of  Rome as the ultimate authority, was known as Ultramontanism, or just Romanism or Papalism, and its main support came from the Jesuits. The long and unresolved struggle, inherited from the Middle Ages, between  spiritual and temporal power, between Pope and Emperor, Archbishop and King, ecclesiastical court and royal court, was very much in evidence in 18th century Europe, and everywhere the Church was losing ground, largely because her leaders so often saw themselves first as the king’s men.
     The Jesuit support for the ‘traditional teaching’ regarding papal prerogatives, thus effecting the serious displeasure of temporal rulers, left them open to retribution. Possessed of real influence and authority, the Jesuits posed a threat to royal and parliamentary power.  By 1769, the start of the pontificat of Clement XIV, they had already been expelled from Portugal and Spain - including their vast overseas possessions, as well as from France, Naples, and Parma, for invariably spurious reasons. In the Spanish colonies, as part of their mission to improve the lot of the indigenous people, the Jesuits had set up thriving businesses and other commercial ventures for the benefit of the local people. The Jesuits themselves made no financial gains from these enterprises, and when they were expelled it left the way open for exploitation by those commercial interests so inclined.  Certain monarchs Maria Theresa, Empress of Austria, and Frederick the Great and Catherine of Russia, did not want to lose the Jesuits, primarily because of their excellent  teaching abilities and inexpensive schools.  In France the suppression was due to the influence of  the ‘Parlement’ of Paris and the provincial Parlements, enemies of long-standing, rather than the reluctant King Louis XV.  In 1773, the Empress Maria Theresa, succumbing to pressure from Charles III of Spain, authorised the banning of  the ‘Society of Jesus’ in Austria, but  insisted that the priests be allowed to remain as teachers wearing lay attire.  Spain, which had already expelled some 4000 Jesuits – 2000 in the Old World and 2000 in the New, continued to pressurise the Pope;  the Ambassador, Jose Monino,  threatening that failure to draw up a ‘Brief of Suppression’ against the Jesuits would result in all the Religious Orders in Spain being suppressed.  He finally produced a document containing eighteen articles which he bullied the Pope into accepting in principle.  In June 1773 Clement XIV issued a Brief suppressing the ‘Society of Jesus’. It was to be 41 years before the Society was  re-instated by Pope Pius VII. 



                               POPE CLEMENT XIV (1769-74)



 Pope Clement XIV died a year after issuing the Brief in what has been described as rather macabre circumstances. He had suffered for some years from a skin disorder, and as a remedy had been imbibing increasing quantities of mercury in the medicines prescribed for him by his doctors. On September 8th,1774,  he collapsed unconscious outside the Quirinale and by the 24th of the month he was dead. His body immediately assumed a black and blue colour and when it was exhibited in St Peter’s, it was necessary to cover the face with a mask. In the popular imagination the manner of his death was either due to the Jesuits who had managed to poison him, or that he had been visited, after the suppression, by the wrath of God. The former theory was immediately dismissed by even those most critical of the Society.
     Impartial historians have admitted that in bringing about the suppression of the Society of Jesus, the enemies of Christianity were aiming to bring down the Catholic Church.  As in every age saints were not lacking to counter the evils that authority seemed powerless to deal with. The Redemptorist missions founded by St Alphonsus Liguori,  undid much of the harm done by the Jansenists;  Primary education was carried on with great sacrifice by the Brothers of St. John Baptist de la  Salle; and the Retreats given by the Passionists founded by St Paul of the Cross led many back to the practice of true religion. But the gap left in higher education by the Jesuits suppression, was not filled. Clement XIV is said to have admitted that by his act of 1773, he had cut off his right hand.'
    In hindsight, it should be recognised that in addition to the heavy responsibilities of Church and State, the Holy Father may well have been unknowingly suffering from the effects of mercury poisoning for some years, which would certainly have effected his physical and mental well-being.

                                                                                                                                                                                                (to be continued)

Sunday, 20 December 2009

'Jesus Christ, God made Man, conceived by the Holy Ghost, born of the Virgin Mary'

With Christmas almost upon us it seems fitting to address our thoughts to Mary, the holy virgin Mother of Jesus Christ.
         In pre-Reformation Catholic England, devotion to the Virgin Mary was an integral part and parcel of people's faith and  lives.  Referring to England of those times in his book  'Our Lady's Dowry', Father Bridgett C.SS.R  describes how  'devotion to Our Lady had the time, space and opportunity to work out its results thoroughly in England;  which devotion sprang from a lively faith in the Incarnation, and in its turn acted as the safeguard of that faith;  how it was an exercise and a stimulant of Christian hope whether in the sinner or the saint, looking as they did on our Lady as the great channel of the mercies of God purchased for us by Jesus Christ;  how it is one of the noblest acts of that charity which makes us love what God loves, and how it led to innumerable works of love and mercy to men; how it gave a charm and attraction to the Christian heart, without in any way substituting mere poetry and sentimentalism for solid virtue'.

Even writers who had least sympathy with the Catholic faith, openly praised the effect of this devotion to our Lady, in developing respect for women.

A certain Mr Lecky in his 'History of Rationalism' wrote:-

'The world is governed by its ideals, and seldom or never has there been one which has exercised a more profound and, on the whole, a more salutory influence than the mediaeval conception of the Virgin. For the first time woman was elevated to her rightful position, and the sanctity of weakness was recognised as well as the sanctity of sorrow.  No longer the slave or the toy of man, no longer associated only with ideas of degradation and of sensuality, woman rose in the person of the Virgin Mother into a new sphere, and became the object of a reverential homage of which antiquity had no conception.  The moral charm and beauty of female excellence was, for the first time, felt. A new type of character was called into being, a new kind of admiration fostered.  Into a harsh and ignorant and benighted age this ideal type infused a conception of gentleness and purity unknown to the proudest generations of the past.  In the pages of living tenderness which many a monkish writer has left in honour of his celestial patron; in the millions who, in many lands and in many ages, have sought, with no barren desire, to mould their characters into her image; in those holy maidens who, for the love of Mary, have separated themselves from all the glories and pleasures of the world, to seek, in fastings and vigils and humble charity, to render themselves worthy of her benediction;  in the new sense of honour, in the chivalrous respect, in the softening of manners, in the refinement of tastes displayed in all the walks of society;   in these, and in many other ways, we detect its influence.  All that was best in Europe clustered around it, and it is the origin of many of the purest elements of our civilisation'.  
               

The 19th century in England brought  Catholic emancipation involving considerable public controversy, particularly following the dogmatic papal  decrees of the Immaculate Conception (1854) and Papal Infallibility (1870).  These were strongly condemned by,  among others, the Rt Hon W.E.Gladstone in his book 'The Vatican Decrees', who stated that 'the growth of what is often termed among Protestants 'Mariolatry' was notoriously advancing of late years, and that the recent papal decrees were deadly blows at the old historic, scientific, and moderate school, and an act of violence'. On the other hand, he also stated  that 'in days within his own memory, the constant, favourite, and imposing argument of Roman controversialists was the unbroken and absolute identity in belief of the Roman Church from the days of our Saviour until now'. 

Fr Bridgett comments that it is certainly not true that 'Rome has substituted for the proud boast of 'semper eadem' a policy of violence and change of faith, and it assuredly ill befits those who accept the inheritance of Henry, Edward, and Elizabeth, to make charges so easy of crushing retort'. 

Furthermore Fr Bridgett continues, 'Could our ancestors, whether Saxon or Norman, rise up at the present day, they would have to make no change of faith, and do no violence to their own feelings, in accepting either the Vatican decrees or any dogmatic decree that has ever issued from the Apostolic Chair of St Peter.  But seeing the face of England, and the ruins of all the things they loved, they would indeed lament that England had substituted for her proud boast of being our Lady's Dowry, a policy of violence and change of faith.' 
            
Fr Bridgett quotes the following prayer of St Anselm, the great and saintly Archbishop of Canterbury in the 11th century, and inviting the reader to repeat this prayer suggests that in reading it he will have no difficulty in recognising the faith and devotion of the Archbishop of Westminster of the 19th century.
      
                               Prayer of St Anselm (11th century)


      ' Of a certainty, O Jesus, Son of God, and thou, O Mother Mary, you desire that whatever you love should be loved by us. Therefore, O good Son, I beg Thee, by the love Thou bearest Thy Mother, and as Thou wishest her to be loved, to grant to me that I may truly love her.  And thou, O good Mother, I beg thee by the love thou bearest thy Son, as thou wishest Him to be loved, to pray for me that I may truly love Him. Behold I ask nothing that is not in accordance with your will. Since then, this is in your power, shall my sins prevent its being done? O Jesus, lover of men, Thou wert able to love criminals even so as to die for them; canst Thou then, refuse me, who ask only the love of Thee and Thy Mother? And thou too, Mary, Mother of Him who loved us, who didst bear Him in thy womb, and feed Him at thy breast, art thou not able, or not willing,  to obtain for one who asks it,  the love of thy Son and of thyself?  O, may then my mind venerate you both as you deserve! may my heart love you, as it is right it should! may my body serve you, as it ought! in your service may my life be spent! and may my whole substance praise you in eternity!  Blessed be God for ever.  Amen, amen.'


             Wishing you peace and happiness for Christmas and the New Year.




'The Last Four Sorrows' of Our Lady' - Charles Journet

  'The Last Four Sorrows of Our Lady' Charles Journet                          Fourth Sorrow   This was Mary’s sufferings ...