Saturday, 21 August 2010

Summer Bonfire and Barbecue on Papa Stronsay

 
Every summer the community of the Sons of the Most Holy Redeemer (F.SS.R) organise a  bonfire evening and barbecue on Papa Stronsay to which all the residents of Stronsay and their friends are invited.
This year, this was held on the evening of the 15th August, the feast of the 'Assumption of Our Blessed Lady', which also was a very special day for  Brother Martin Mary F.SS.R who earlier that day in the monastery chapel, had taken  his final vows.

The trip to Papa Stronsay  was scheduled for 6.30p.m. from the Stronsay main pier, with  transport provided by SS St Alphonsus under its erstwhile captain, Fr Anthony Mary F.SS.R.with passengers numbering about 50, including many children.

            
'Torchman' beating measured retreat after lighting bonfire!

The grand lighting of the bonfire was at about 7.15p.m. with Brother Martin's father having the  'honour' of principal fire-lighter.As the flames were taking hold, and from a suitably discreet distance, Fr Michael Mary F.SS.R administered the traditional blessing.
   
 

 Fr Michael Mary F.SS.R. blessing the fire - at a discreet distance!

The bonfire itself comprised basically  old, discarded wooden pallets, and  was about 20 feet tall and a decidedly compact 10.feet square. I am 'reliably informed' that the principal architect and also builder was Brother Nicodemus F.SS.R,  with perhaps some 'advice' and 'assistance' from  fellow confreres!  It was ingeniously constructed in true Meccano, or should I say Lego style, with an intriguing  wooden bird-house (unoccupied!) near the top, surmounted by a large and mysterious, but rather tatty unidentifiable flag, and on the side at ground level a cunningly marked opening indicated  by a bluecloth, through which the 'torchman' thrust the flaming spill'                                                        


The bonfire's  going well!

Everything went according to plan, not necessarily always the case on these occasions, with the bonfire lighting first time and providing a fine spectacle to all on Papa Stronsay and also those across the water on Stronsay, with  glowing embers and sparks lighting the skyline for many hours.


 That poor bird-house!

The buffet meal was lavish with a wide choice of tasty food, fresh-cooked sausages and other barbecued delicacies, choice of salads with ingredients grown in the monastic greenhouse, individual carrot and cheese dishes in garlic, prepared by Sister Onufria, a Basilian Sister, a visitor to Stronsay from the Ukraine,  and other delights too numerous to mention. Two large trays of home-made scones were provided by a generous donor from Stronsay who I will not mention by name, but whose generosity to all good causes is well known. The liquid refreshment ranged from tea, coffee and lemonade, through to wine and longer alcoholic beverages. I enjoyed a glass of draught Guiness which was just right for the occasion. Fr Michael and  Fr Anthony and all the Brothers were hospitality itself, cooking and serving the food and drink, and meeting and talking with everybody. 

  
                     'Cure d'Ars' shrine in monastery grounds

Many visitors explored the monastery greenhouse, where flowers, vegetables and fruit, including peaches, grapes and soft fruit, proliferate. There is  currently  an excess of courgettes, and  Val Lucas, one of the guests, was given one of the  biggest courgettes that I have ever seen. It weighed approximately 5lb and was about 2 feet in length! Proof of the pudding is in the eating, and although I did not eat it, I was able to photograph Val staggering under its weight on her way home! 


Val Lucas with the biggest courgette (aspidestra?) in the world!

Several guests visited the beautiful and usable, but as yet unfinished 'Purgatorial Association' chapel, specially set aside for prayer and intercession  for the 'Holy Souls' in Purgatory.
It was a truly memorable and enjoyable evening, and although our family party left at about 10p.m. in the small boat, there were still many enjoying the balmy summer's night on Papa Stronsay with much merriment and song around the glowing embers. 

           
Getting dark - embers starting to glow!

I understand it was past midnight before the ferry made its final trip to Stronsay and back.

For lots more about Br Martin Mary F.SS.R and his special day, also a little more about the bonfire and barbecue, see today's Post on the 'Transalpine Redemptorist' blogsite - link on my side-bar. 

'Drive away sadness, preserving your tranquillity and a cheerful countenance in all events, with a constant uniformity.  He who wills what God wills should never be downcast'  (St Alphonsus (1696-1787) - founder of the Redemptorist Order)

Sunday, 18 July 2010

UK Government's £407 million pledged to international abortion agency

Today is the Feast Day of the 'Solemnity of The Most Holy Redeemer' - a very special day for the Sons of the Most Holy Redeemer (F.SS.R).
Here on Stronsay, we had a beautiful sung Mass - no.2 in the Liber Usualis (Kyrie fons bonitatis), with the Proper of the Mass, and motet for 3 voices - 'Panis Angelicus' by Casciolini. The Mass was celebrated by Fr Anthony Mary F.SS.R, with Fr Michael Mary F.SS.R and the Brothers in attendance. (See 'Transalpine Redemptorist' link on side-bar)
                                              *************************************
 'Render to God the things that are God's, and to Caesar the things that are Caesar's'


£47,000,000 Grant over 5 years, by UK AID to fund ‘sexual and reproductive health and rights for all’ PLUS
£360,000,000 over 2 years, from UK, promised by Prime Minister, David Cameron, at G8 Summit 2010, for the same purpose. 
  http://www.ippf.org/en/Resources/Statements/G8+Maternal+Health+Initiative+must+include+funding+for+family+planning.htm


What do we think about this?    
 With the government looking  to save money, one department surely deserving of scrutiny must be the ‘Department for International Development (DFID)’, responsible for distributing UK Aid (taxpayer’s money) to worthwhile causes overseas. One particular organisation, little known to most people, the recipient of huge funding from the UK and other western governments, is the ‘International Planned Parenthood Federation (IPPF)’. 

‘IPPF is a global service provider and a leading advocate of sexual and reproductive health and rights for all’.  This rather grand statement could be interpreted as 'a global supplier of  contraceptives and  abortion facilities, and access to these - particularly for women in poor countries.' 
 

 Founded by the American birth-control activist and founder of the American Birth Control League, Margaret Sanger, in 1952,  IPPF has six Regional Offices, with headquarters in London, employing over 300 people, and with  a global network of Member Associations in over 170 countries.  It is no coincidence that the origins of IPPF can be traced back to the Eugenics movement of the early 20th century, when contraception and abortion were regarded  as a means of population control, especially in those countries now considered third world countries, and with euthanasia proposed for certain ‘mentally retarded and  criminal elements of society’.

Bitter opponents of the Catholic Church and ‘pro-life’ and ‘anti-abortion’ organisations, the IPPF presents a liberal and humanist ethos.  It receives financial support from the governments of most Western nations, particularly from the Scandinavian countries, from  the USA,  Australia, New Zealand, and Canada, with  wealthy  philanthropic organisations like the Bill Gates Foundation, providing a substantial and continuing flow of income.

For the period 1st April 2008 - 1st March 2013, the UK government  approved a Grant of £43,000,000  to support the ‘core work objectives of the International Planned Parenthood Federation (IPPF).’ In addition, at the G8 Summit meeting this year, David Cameron pledged an additional £360,000,000 aid over 2 years.  Additionally the UK government made a further Grant of £4,000,000  for the ‘IPPF Safe Abortion Action Fund’(SAAF)  for the period 01/03/2007 to 01/03/2009, a  fund  for the ‘increased utilisation of quality safe abortion and post abortion services, especially by young, poor, and vulnerable women’  
 SAAF
 Additionally, £46,525 was paid into the same Fund for the period 01/04/2009 to 31/05/2009.                   

 The IPPF is a registered UK charity, with 11 of its employees earning £60,000 plus P.A.,  7 earning £100,000 plus P.A., and the top earner on £228,000 P.A. 
 http://www.ippf.org/NR/rdonlyres/32AEAA76-7D95-49Financial Statements 2009


The IPPF is not part of any government sector, and there appear to be no conditions attached to the grants.
 The funding is for ‘procurement of services relating to population policies/programmes and reproductive health care’ worldwide.Its purpose and objective is geared to population control, with a projected policy of contraception and abortion for young, poor and vulnerable women, particularly in Third World and poorer countries.  It has a commercial arm dealing in the marketing and supply of contraceptives.             


An official partnership programme between DFID and IPPF has been set up, in which the DFID’s  Policy Division  ‘recognises the specific role of IPPF in implementing DFID policy in the areas of sexual and reproductive health and rights, AIDS and maternal health, requiring sustained high-level advocacy work and international leadership in a difficult policy environment’    (N.B.. It appears from the DFID website that the current £47,046,525 funding went solely to projects in Bangladesh) http://www.dfid.gov.uk

I’m sure that most reasonable people would agree, that as a nation and where possible, we must help those less fortunate than ourselves. To provide funds to feed the starving, home the homeless, help those suffering from the effects of war or natural disasters, bring hope to the despairing, and other similar situations, are all clearly good causes. However the provision of ‘contraception and abortion facilities’, is not in this category. Tax-payers have a legitimate interest in the beneficiaries of these huge grants, after all it is their money that the government is giving away, and very many on religious and/or ethical grounds consider this an evil cause, as I do, with many others, on purely rational grounds, opposed to such 'open-handed generosity' in today's difficult economic climate.

 The government has asked for our views on saving their (our) money. A letter or e-mail to one of the Ministers listed below, complaining of  a) the use to which these very substantial Grants will be put; b) the nature of the organisation to which the Grants are made; and  c) the very significant sums of (tax-payers) money funding these Grants, money which could be better used supporting our own fragile public services such as health, education, housing, employment, etc. - would seem called for. If these fact were more generally known I believe that there would be public outrage. The government must be called to account - this funding must stop.
Secretary of State for International Development - Rt Hon Andrew Mitchell MP 
Minister of State for International Development - Alan Duncan MP
Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State for International Development - Stephen O'Brien MP 


 ‘There are three kinds of lies -  lies, damned lies, and statistics' (attributed to various sources).

  The following statement was made by Gill Greer, IPPF Director General, concerning  promises of further financial funding made at the G8 Summit this year:-
 “This is a significant step forward in saving the lives of world’s most vulnerable women and children. Ideological motivations meant that life saving family planning was purposefully omitted from the Millennium Development Goals, and therefore many funding decisions, until 2008. In those eight years, the consequence of sidelining access to modern methods of family planning was the death of 5.1 million women and 1.2 million children. A further 4.8 million children were orphaned. The political leadership, and the funds that must surely follow, of the G8 and other countries will help prevent this human tragedy from ever occurring again.”
 http://www.ippf.org/NR/rdonlyres/32AEAA76-7D95-49F6-8665-9D50FB4F83E9/0/IPPFFinancialStatements2009.pdf


How can Gill Greer possibly guess, let alone present as fact, the mortality and orphan figures she quotes?   They appear as figures plucked from the lottery, impossible to check, impressive to those who want to be impressed, but otherwise wildly speculative.  She does not mention the possible number of unborn babies that would have been killed in one way or another, had modern methods of family planning been adopted 8 years previously. This quote, and the rest of the same IPPF report, throws out numbers like confetti at a wedding, and has the stamp of political spin. There is  no reference to the known adverse physical and psychological effects of contraception and abortion, or the moral or ethical issues involved.  


To conclude, with thanks to ‘Eugenics-Watch’ website
 
‘On one side are the rich and powerful eugenicists, the followers of Malthus by way of Darwin. These Scrooges think that there are too many sick, too many old, too many inferior, too many Chinese, too many Indians, too many, too many, too many people. They want to take evolution into their own qualified, elite, wonderful hands; they don't believe in the sanctity of life or in democracy, its political expression; and they have learned nothing from the series of social disasters which their policies have inflicted on this century - except to be careful not to get caught. That's one choice.
‘And on the other side, there are the orthodox Catholics who believe that the world was made by a great and loving Creator on behalf of persons, all of whom are immortal souls from the moment of conception. Catholics believe that the world has a Redeemer, Jesus Christ; and a mother to teach it unselfishness - the great Mother of God, Mary most holy. Therefore they oppose that degradation of human beings which is eugenics, and support democracy. That's another choice.’
 
                          

Recommended website for further information on Margaret Sanger, eugenicism, and the IPPF        -      http://www.trdd.org

 N.B.   Please also see website for 'Les Femmes - the Truth', who   has an interesting current post on Margaret Sanger; there is a link to this website on my sidebar.

Wednesday, 16 June 2010

Pope Pius VII and Napoleon ----the Last Post

(Continued from the previous post - final instalment)   

Consalvi’s  political achievement at the Congress appeared  to be a great success, but it was not long before deep disillusionment set in, primarily because stable rule in the Legations had become untenable. Historically the Legations had never liked rule from Rome, a dislike rooted in their inaccessibility across the Appenines, in the independent cultural tradition of Bologna, and in their economic interests which were in  the plain of Lombardy rather than southwards. To these factors could now be added some seventeen years separation from the papacy, of union with Lombardy, and of French political, judicial, and administrative institutions. The French had been hard taskmasters, but they had brought into positions of power Italian laymen who had never previously enjoyed any share in the government , and who would  now find it extremely difficult  to hand it back to the clergy. Economically, the Legations were the only profitable part of the Papal States, and without these the remaining territory was  unviable. On a human level, both Pope Pius VI and VII  and their immediate predecessors, came from the area of Cesena, and Pius VII was Bishop of Imola, as was the future Pope Pius IX. Thus, in the first half of the 19th century, the roots of the Papacy as well as the roots of revolutionary liberalism, lay in that fertile region of the valley of the River Po.
  
                                 Tsar Alexandra 1st

After the Congress, the great powers – the Bourbons and the Hapsburgs, together with Tsar Alexandra, sought to secure the blessing of the Pope for the new political arrangement. Although the Church had suffered as a result of liberal revolution, and it was not yet evident in 1815 that the times of disturbance were over, Pope Pius VII guided by Consalvi, refused to commit the papacy to any particular political allegiance, insisting on maintaining strict neutrality. The Congress of Vienna laid the basis for the Congress system, designed by Metternich to extinguish the flames of revolution wherever they might appear, and under the influence of Tsar Alexander, invoking spiritual sanctions in the formation of the Holy Alliance. There seemed a real possibility of a revival of Josephism, and the Papacy preferred to keep its distance.
  
                                       Cardinal Consalvi

Personally, Consalvi viewed  the Congress system and the Holy Alliance as a clumsy attempt to patch up the political structure of European society, an exercise which he considered bound to fail. He saw it as a futile military system which did not take into account the need to guide men’s minds – which to Consalvi meant the need for censorship. In particular he viewed the freedom of the Press, as established in France by Royal Charter, as:-
                   ‘the most dangerous weapon ever put into the hands of the opponents of religion and the monarchy. The liberty of the Press is no mere passing or limited evil, it will be permanent and will develop, so to speak, with each public crisis and with each social upheaval.  The perils to which it gives rise are palpable and incalculable; its advantages and benefits, will be nullified by criminal influences. …….. without doubt, it is with this hidden power, brought into play the whole time and playing simultaneously on the different passions, that it will be necessary to reckon one day……..anonymity will soon be the arbiter of public conscience, and it will be necessary to bend the brow beneath the pen or beneath the whip of masters without name, from whom our subservience will have earned us our alms.  Some see the peril and smilingly ignore it, others accept it as an experiment; nobody will understand that it amounts to infecting whole populations with a fever unrelenting and timeless.  ……..the struggle between the good and evil principle will never be equally matched. Talent, even genius, cannot triumph in these daily combats in which pens venal and filled with hatred,  take issue with men of goodwill, distorting their characters and behaviour, and putting themselves forward as the sole defenders of the people and of liberty’.
      
      Paradoxically, and for almost the opposite reason, the English and the continental liberals of the day also condemned the Congress System and the Holy Alliance, seeing in them an instrument for shackling the peoples of Europe, to prevent them  being emancipated by the principles of the French Revolution, viz. liberty, equality, and fraternity.  The later French revolutions of the 19th century would show that both Cardinal Consalvi and Chancellor Metternich were correct in anticipating that  journalism would have a powerful and influential role in promoting public unrest. However the Cardinal’s distinction between the ‘good principle’ and ‘men of bad faith’, would be shown to be as much an over-simplification as the  classification of  Europeans by the revolutionary Mazzini, as either ‘liberals' or ‘ruling classes’.
                            
                          Giuseppe Mazzini - Italian Revolutionary

In the Carlsbad Decrees (1819) and the Congress of Troppau (1820), Metternich introduced strict censorship laws designed to prevent the publication of liberal revolutionary sentiments in the Press. Consalvi approved of this, but when it came to collective military intervention to quash  revolutionary activity, he was not prepared to involve the Papal forces in any way.  He was in fact, attempting to maintain two conflicting policies; first the suppression of the secret societies and revolutionary movements, and second an absolute neutrality for the Papal States; a policy of isolationism which was to be adhered to,  in spite of  any ideological sympathies Rome might have.  It was apparent that this could not prevail for long, for only  when the power of France and that of Austria were finely balanced in Italy, was there any chance at all of Rome retaining her independence. When  revolution struck in her own territories in 1831-2 the Austrians were called in to help, and in 1848 it was the turn of the French. The only hope of safeguarding the frontiers reclaimed at the Congress, lay in the collective security system demanded by Metternich. With only a token army and without proscription- which the Popes would not countenance, the main ‘hope’for the avoidance of war and alliances, was the concept  that it was sacrilegious for lay rulers or revolutionaries to lay hands on papal territory. In spite of  Consalvi’s eloquence, such a concept failed to carry conviction in 19th century Europe.
    
                          Prince von Metternich - German diplomat

After the Congress, Consalvi sought to gradually reconstruct the Papal system of government, at the same time retaining what was good in  the Napoleonic system. The main aim was for administrative centralization, and secularization in those matters deemed appropriate, particularly with regard to judicial powers which were not to be held by religious legates or delegates, nor to be exercised by priests excepting ecclesiastical courts dealing with the clergy, or matters of canon law. The Consalvi programme was not popular with those who wanted to see the old ways restored, and it did not go far enough in providing opportunities for political power to those  laymen of the Legations who had already tasted  this under French rule. Consalvi did succeed in introducing new measures for regulating the roads and water supplies,  re-organising the institutions of higher education, and setting-up a new code of civil procedure. In Rome he was responsible for the re-assessment of rates so that the better-class properties paid more towards the maintenance of Rome’s roads, fountains and ancient monuments.
              
       Basilica of St John Lateran - Cathedral of the Bishop of Rome

The social and economic conditions were difficult, with a rapidly increasing population coupled with severe failure of the harvest in 1816, necessitating severe trade restrictions on the export of grain. Subsidies were paid to prevent the savings-banks of the poor from defaulting, and payments continued to be made to mayors of impoverished townships to enable them to help the starving poor. Taxation had to be increased, a necessary but unwelcome step.  Crime proliferated, particularly in the hills and in the Legations, with organised banditry and increasing numbers of revolutionary and secret societies fomenting civil unrest.The oldest and most widespread of these was the 'Carbonari', founded in Naples in the early 19th century, with the avowed aim of bringing about a united Italy free from papal and foreign rule.Inadequate and insufficient military and police, led to the formation of voluntary bands of ‘Sanfedisti’ or ‘Centurions’ as a self-appointed police force – misguidedly encouraged by certain Cardinal legates but responsible to none, and which ultimately attracted violent and unruly men, a law unto themselves. As so often happens in difficult times,God raises men and women of heroic sanctity to proclaim His message to the world. After the Revolution and the Napoleonic Wars, the Church in Austria, Germany, and Poland, was in grave danger of total collapse, with true Catholic preaching scarcely heard. The spirit of Jansenism, in the form of religious rationalism, was rampant; devotion to Our Lady had all but disappeared - particularly with regard to praying the Rosary; and the liturgy in the Mass neglected, with vestments, chants, and settings no longer important. A Redemptorist priest, Fr Clement Mary Hofbauer, succeeded against tremendous odds in founding branches of his Congregation in these countries, with the blessing, encouragement, and practical help of Pope Pius VII and the diplomatic skills of Cardinal Consalvi. Due to the heroic work and sanctity of Fr Hofbauer, now St Clement Mary Hofbauer, and many other good priests and religious, Catholicism was saved and the way paved for true renewal and reunion - 'the German dioceses were reanimated by the living breath of the papacy, out of the ruins of an upheaved world' (Papal History of Later Times - Ludwig von Pastor)

                                 St Clement Mary Hofbauer C.SS.R

A notable cause of public resentment  and increasing unrest, was the harsh punishment meted out in 1816 to those who had cooperated  with the French, regardless of individual circumstances. This was the responsibility of  Cardinal Pacca,  appointed  pro-Secretary of State in the absence of Consalvi who was away in Vienna, and who viewed almost anything connected with the Revolution as diabolic in origin.   This 'hard-line' policy whilst occasionally necessary, was generally not in line with the thinking of Pope Pius VII, nor with that of Consalvi. However the Pope, whilst fearless and forthright in speaking out on  matters of faith and the Church, was always reluctant to interfere in matters of State delegated to others to deal with.   In the long run the fate of the Papal States would be sealed by the fact that the geography, politics, and the climate of opinion were to make it impossible to continue to run an independent theocracy in the centre of the Italian peninsula. 
      
     On the 14th anniversary of Radet’s attack on the Quirinal, July 6th 1823, the 81 year old Pope fell, whilst alone in his study, and broke his thigh-bone. He was too feeble to survive an operation, and on August 20th he died.  Symbolically, even as the Pope lay dying, the most historic of the city’s great basilicas, Saint Paul’s without the Walls, was going up in flames. A great pontificate had ended. No doubt that Pius VII physically was not the man after the restoration that he had been before, and he became increasingly feeble after a fall in 1817. But since his long struggle with Napoleon he had never ceased to be a legendary figure, and for many years he would be looked upon as ‘the good Pope’

    Marble sculpture of Pope Pius VII by Bertel Thorvaldsen, in the Clementine Chapel in the Vatican

Within a few weeks Cardinal Della Genga, was elected Pope, taking the name of Leo XII, and within a few months, Cardinal Consalvi, the friend and loyal servant of Pope Pius VII, was dead.  

      Considerable mention has been made of the achievements of Consalvi, but it must be remembered  that he was a close friend and loyal servant of Pope Pius VII over many years, and that everything he did was almost certainly either at  the Pope’s request or with his agreement and blessing. The Pope himself is remembered as a builder and beautifier of the city of Rome, as well as a patron of the arts. He was responsible for the return to Rome of many valuable and sacred works of art expropriated by the French and removed to Paris. He was also responsible for undertaking the finding and identifying of the mortal remains of St Francis of Assisi, culminating in the papal decree ‘Assisiensem basilicam’ (1820). Neither did he forget his old adversary Napoleon for whom, in spite of everything, he maintained a genuine concern. The Pope arranged for a chaplain to stay with Napoleon in St Helena, who remained there until the Emperor’s death in May,1821.       
   
                        Napoleon on his death-bed

During the years of the Emperor’s exile, the Pope used sometimes to meet the Emperor’s mother to whom he had given refuge in Rome. They would talk of ‘the good Emperor’, for whom the Pope through Consalvi, had intervened with the Prince Regent of England and allied Sovereigns, to soften the rigors of his confinement in St Helena. Interestingly, through Consalvi, Pius has written of Napoleon as follows:-     
        ‘The re-establishment of religion in the great kingdom of France, was principally owing after God, to him. The dutiful and courageous initiative of 1801 made Us long forget and forgive subsequent injuries. Savona and Fontainebleu were but actions of a misled mind, aberrations of human ambition, whilst the Concordat was a saving act undertaken in a Christian and heroic spirit.’
          
Madame Mere Letizia, the Emperor’s mother, wrote thanking the Pontiff:-
    ‘The mother of kings has become the mother of sorrows. The one consolation that remains is the thought of the Holy Father’s having forgotten the past, and remembering only the affection he has shown us all. Under the pontifical government alone have we found support and shelter.Our gratitude is as great as the benefit conferred. His Holiness and Your Eminence are the only ones who have sought to mitigate the sufferings of him whose life is ebbing away on that desert- rock island. I thank you with all my mother’s heart."

                      Napoleon's House of Exile in St Helena

Her brother, Cardinal Fesch, said, “God did not break Napoleon, He humbled him; and in humility lies salvation.”  Napoleon’s exile corresponded almost exactly to the six years he had kept the Pope prisoner in Rome, Savona, and Fontainebleu, only his own captivity was significantly harsher. The roof of his ramshackle residence, infested by rats and bugs, let in rain; his food was not of the right kind and severely rationed; his correspondence was intercepted or withheld. After a time he was not allowed out of the house, then not out of his room, and finally was unable to show himself at the window without being insulted. It is recorded that he attended Mass and availed himself of the Sacrament of Confession, and prior to his death asked for the Last Sacraments. Who can say how much the memory of Pius VII’s goodness, patience and charity in persecution and above all, the Pope’s prayers, contributed in effecting, at the last, a holy death?


Ack.  -- 'Revolution and Papacy' by E.E.Y.Hales (Hanover House 1960)
          --'Pope Pius VII 1800-1823' by Robin Anderson (Tan Books 2001)

Saturday, 15 May 2010

Pope Pius VII and Napoleon - the Way of the Cross

 (Continued from previous post)

At midnight on June 9, 1812 , with great secrecy, Pope Pius was removed from his residence in Savona, disguised in black as a simple priest, accompanied only by his doctor, to be taken by horse and carriage to  Fontainbleau. The route included  Genoa, Turin, and Mont Cenis where the Pope was confined to his bed in the monastery suffering from a serious and painful urinary problem, accompanied by a fever. His condition worsened to the extent that he received the Last Rites from the Abbot. The Pope’s own doctor demanded that a specialist doctor be called as he felt unable to cope. All that was allowed was that a local doctor be summoned, and on June 15th the journey resumed with the Pope carried into the coach and laid on an improvised bed, accompanied by the new doctor. Four days later they reached Fontainbleau where the Pope remained in his bed too ill to be moved.

                              FONTAINBLEAU  PALACE

That he had survived the journey was due in no small measure to the competence and dedication of the doctor, Dr Claraz, who cared for his charge all hours of the day and night. Slowly the Pope’s condition improved and he was able to see visitors.  In January 1813 he was visited by Napoleon, who unbeknown to the Pope, had suffered a disastrous setback in his Russian campaign.  The Pope was also ignorant of the increasing opposition to the Emperor and the growing support for himself among the clergy in France and Italy. He was unaware of the violent treatment of the more obdurate and loyal Bishops, of the enforced closure of the great seminary of St Sulpice and the purging of the professors of other seminaries, of increasing anti-Gallican sentiments among the younger clergy, and that cathedral chapters would no longer passively elect the Emperor’s Episcopal nominees as their administrators. The Pope was also still physically and mentally exhausted.  Cardinal Pacca, imprisoned and out of touch with the Pope,  later had this to say, ‘Knowing as I did the quiet and gentle disposition of the Pope, and that he was battered and brought low by illness, suffering, and the hardship of a long imprisonment, and knowing him to be surrounded by people who had either sold themselves altogether to the Emperor, or were miserably timid and behaved like courtiers, I realized at once that the struggle between Gregory Barnabas Chiaramonti and Napoleon Ponaparte would be conducted with forces too unequal in strength, and I saw which side would gain the victory—'.  

                                 CARDINAL PACCA

A new Concordat was drawn up which included full recognition of the Pope as a sovereign, but not as a sovereign over Rome, with the seat of the papacy left undecided; investiture of bishops by Metropolitans, after a six months interval, but  with nominations and investiture of bishops in the patrimony of St Peter reserved to the Pope; and release of the cardinals (known as black cardinals) and bishops imprisoned by the Emperor. 

When Cardinal Pacca after his release, met the Pope at Fontainbleau in February 1813, the first meeting between the two for three and a half years, he found him ‘bent, pale, emaciated, with his eyes sunk deep into his head, and motionless as though he were dazed’ When told by the cardinal of his joy at seeing him again, bearing witness to his admiration for the heroic constancy with which he had suffered so long and grievous an imprisonment, the Pope was filled with distress, and replied “But in the end I was defiled. Those cardinals ----- they dragged me to the table and made me sign”.

The Pope told the Cardinal that prior to the meeting with Napoleon, four cardinals and four bishops had been sent with impossible demands, which included the nomination of two-thirds of the Sacred College by the Catholic Sovereigns, the condemnation by the Pope of the ‘black cardinals’ who had declined to attend the Emperor’s ‘marriage’, and the establishment of the Papacy in Paris. The Pope had refused to consider these requests, but on the arrival of Napoleon himself, cordial and threatening by turns, he was persuaded that the Church had to be reconciled with the Revolution and the New Order in Europe, embodied in the Emperor, and that she had everything to gain by relinquishing all idea of temporal power.  The ‘red cardinals’ and French prelates by whom the Pope was surrounded, were equally persuasive, and  these were the men who ‘dragged me to the table and made me sign’. 

The ultramontanes refused to believe that the Pope could, by implication, have signed away the temporal power, or have yielded over the investiture of bishops. They were in fact correct, for the Pope had not signed a Concordat as such, instead he had signed certain ‘Heads of Proposals’, deliberately worded as being only of a provisional nature, and intended to serve as a basis for an understanding, and which the signatorees had agreed should remain confidential. In publishing the details at all Napoleon was in breach of trust, and in publishing it as a Concordat, he was guilty of  misrepresentation.   The Pope was now joined by three of his ablest and loyal servants, Cardinals Consalvi, di Pietro, and Pacca, who with Cardinals Gabrielli, Mattei, and Della Somaglia, constituted the Pope’s close cabinet, and who with his support pushed through the difficult policy of cancelling the ‘Concordat of Fontainbleau’, against the advice of the majority of the cardinals, and in face of the certainty of the Emperor’s wrath.

                                            NAPOLEON

Pope Pius wrote a personal letter to Napoleon, in which he expressed his surprise that provisional proposals for an agreement had been published as a Concordat, and that his conscience revolted against the proposals, and that he had only signed them out of ‘human frailty, being only dust and ashes’, but that he was willing to negotiate a definite settlement. After writing this letter, which was carried to Napoleon on 24th March, the Pope’s whole mood changed for the better, regaining his amiability and  recovering his appetite. Napoleon kept this letter secret, realising that the Pope had been helped in his course of action, and decreed that he was to be kept isolated once again, and that he would settle the matter on his return from the German campaign. But in October, his defeat at the Battle of the Nations at Leipzig, signalled the beginning of the end for Napoleon's ambitions.

          BATTLE OF THE NATIONS, LEIPZIG   OCTOBER 1813

Urgent overtures were made  to the Pope to ‘enlist’ his support, but  the Pope was now  sufficiently aware of worldly affairs,  and declined to negotiate until he had been returned to Rome, with full liberty  restored and surrounded by the Sacred College. By the end of January 1814, Napoleon was forced by pressure of circumstances,  to authorise the Pope's departure from Fontainbleau,  and his return to Rome. King Murat of Naples was in control of  Rome and had planned to enlarge his own kingdom to include Rome and much of Italy. On meeting the Pope he presented him with a petition signed by his friends, demanding a temporal ruler. The Pope’s answer was to throw the petition into the fire, exclaiming, ’Now there remains no obstacle to our returning to Rome’. 

The Pope entered Rome in triumph on May 24, 1814. On a parallel road not far away, Napoleon in fear of his life, was heading south for Frejus,  travelling only by night,  and soon to be banished to Elba.

                                   BANISHED TO ELBA!

On  August 17, 1814, the feast day of St Ignatius of Loyola, the Pope published a Bull which vindicated and restored the Society of Jesus, and in which he expressly repealed the Bull of Pope Clement XIV,  ‘Dominus ac Redemptor Noster’ (July 1773) which had confirmed the  suppression of the Society.     Rome now enjoyed a period of ultramontane revival, due primarily to the admiration and respect in which the Pope was held. The older Religious Orders enjoyed a noticeable revival, and many new Orders were formed. This enthusiasm  was not shared by all of the great Powers, with Russia, Germany, Austria, France, and others, still ambitious for temporal gains and power, and some still openly Josephist or Gallican in their attitude to Rome. At the Congress of Vienna in September 1814, the Pope was represented by his Secretary of State, Cardinal Consalvi, whose main objective was the full restitution of the former possessions of the Holy See.

                                   CARDINAL CONSALVI

Remarkably after negotiations lasting nine months, and utilising the  principles of hereditary rights and legitimacy, and the restoration of the ‘status quo’ prior to the revolution, Consalvi achieved his aim. Although the Great Powers were desirous of increasing their territories, this could only be done at the expense of either the Papacy or one another, and it became apparent that it was in everyone’s interest for the Papal States which included the Legations, to revert back to Rome. King Murat of Naples, the controller of Rome and much of the Papal States, which he had acquired from Metternich as a reward for switching his allegiance from the French to the Austrian cause,  was not prepared to give these up lightly.  He had secretly been in touch with Napoleon currently on the Isle of Elba, promising to enlist popular and military support for him in Italy whenever he chose to return. 

                       NAPOLEON'S RESIDENCE ON ELBA

At the end of February 1815, Napoleon left Elba intent on consolidating his forces in Italy and making his way  to France. Meanwhile Murat  marched his troops north through Italy, inviting not only the citizens of  Rome, the Marches and the legations, but also those of Turin, Milan and Venice,  to prepare a constitution for an independent Italy.  The Pope prudently withdrew from Rome, visiting Genoa, Modena, Florence, Siena, and Viterbo,  addressing and praying with his people, strengthening the already widespread and popular esteem  in which he was held. 

                                          POPE PIUS VII

Murat's efforts to enlist support for Napoleon were a  failure, and after one or two minor  victories, his  forces were routed  at  Tolentino, after which he fled to France.

 On June 9, 1815, less than one week before the battle of Waterloo, the final act of the Congress of Vienna was to restore the temporal power of the Papacy to that of 20 years earlier. Consalvi attributed the remarkable success of his mission, entirely to the merits and high esteem in which Pope Pius VII was held throughout Europe,  largely due to the manner in which he had stood up to Napoleon, the common enemy. At that time temporal authority was considered by Rome to be essential  for the effective exercise of spiritual authority,  as this enabled the Papacy to retain its independence, which was a keystone in  papal diplomacy throughout the reign of Pius VII. As the 19th century progressed, significant political, social and economic changes  were to cloud this absolute view to a degree which could not have been foreseen or even thought possible in 1815. In hindsight it could be said that although Consalvi’s achievement at Vienna was indeed remarkable and  considered highly successful at the time,  events in the longer term  were to prove it to have been a disaster, for the restoration of Rome's temporal power was later to cause more problems than it had solved.
          
                                                    (final episode to follow)
                          
(ack ‘Revolution and Papacy’ by EEY.Hales.   Published Hanover House1960)                                                       

Tuesday, 13 April 2010

Pope Pius VII and Napoleon - Savona. 1809-1812

(Continued from previous post)

The journey that had begun in Rome an hour after dawn, continued until midnight, in the stifling heat of July, with the carriage windows closed to avoid recognition, and only one short stop for a meal. The Pope was 66 years old and of slight physique, and suffered extreme discomfort from the long and tiring journey, made worse by an attack of dysentry.   The first night was spent in a small hostelry in the Tuscan hills, and General Radet planned for his charge to reach Florence by the following evening. This was not to be, for Pius developed a high fever and was confined to his bed for much of the next day; also he refused to continue the journey until the arrival of his private chaplain, his doctor, his cook and servant, plus necessary clothing and accoutrements. These arrived later that day, and the Pope's journey  re-commenced early the following morning.


 During the journey a wheel came off the carriage in which  the Holy Father and Cardinal Pacca were travelling, causing it to topple over. Fortunately neither the Pope nor the cardinal were hurt,  those most shaken being Radet, who had been thrown into a ditch, and the accompanying guards. After necessary repairs the journey continued, and Florence was reached by nightfall.  The Pope was completely exhausted, refusing the meal prepared by the monks of Charterhouse where he was staying, and retiring immediately to bed. He had little rest, for during the night the Grand Duchess sent a message that he was to leave Tuscany immediately, and was to be taken to Grenoble, the fortified headquarters of a  French army division.


After only a few days in Grenoble, and following clarification of Bonaparte's original orders which had initially been misunderstood, the Pope found himself returning  alone to Savona , without his  friend and companion Cardinal Pacca, who had been moved to the Fenestrelle fortress  in the mountains of Savoy. The Pope’s journey  included Romans, Valence - where Pope Pius VI had died in captivity ten years earlier, Avignon, Marseilles and  Nice, where the people turned out in huge numbers to show their support for the Holy Father, and finally Savona, arriving there on August 17th.

                                SAVONA  CATHEDRAL

 The Pope was lodged in the Episcopal palace, and provided with two or three personal servants, books and writing facilities, but he had no companions of like mind with whom he could discuss Church affairs, nor a confessor of his choice. Because of this, he declined to negotiate with Napoleon’s envoys on Church matters, insisting that to do this, he must be free and  enabled  to perform his functions as Pope, with proper consultative and administrative powers.

This situation was to prevail for the next five years, the Pope virtually adopting  the life-style of a simple Benedictine monk. Initially he managed to write a few letters which were smuggled out of the palace, but after eighteen months one of these letters fell into the hands of the secret police, and Napoleon ordered that his paper, pen and ink were to be taken away. In Savona as everywhere else, it was strictly forbidden to publish anything about the Pope in newspapers, books or pamphlet

       NAPOLEON BONAPARTE  -  (De La Roche 1845 - Posthumous portrait)

It was not long before Napoleon realised  that  the administration of the Church  was being  seriously hampered by the Pope’s refusal to ratify bishops to vacant sees, and this was creating additional problems for him. He thus persuaded certain  Cardinals to write to the Pope to encourage him, ‘in the interests of the Church’, to ratify those new Bishops chosen by the Emperor. The Pope was unimpressed, remaining firm in his refusal to negotiate.  As time went on, more and more people visited Savona - virtually as pilgrims, to catch a glimpse of the Pope, either in his chapel where he celebrated daily Mass, or on  the balcony of the episcopal Palace,  from where he regularly addressed the crowds. There were reports of miraculous cures and favours granted, these reports spreading far beyond the boundaries of Savona.

      SANCTUARY OF OUR LADY OF MERCY, SAVONA.

In view of the Pope’s increasing popularity, Napoleon decided on a change of plan whereby he would show that the Pope’s stay in Savona was as a 'guest'  rather than a prisoner;  that it was merely a temporary protective measure, and that he as the Emperor, was foremost in showing him due respect and honour.  He then arranged for a delegation to visit the Pope to ensure that he was appropriately accommodated and to persuade him to agree to setting up a Consistory of Cardinals and a Chancellery, with members chosen by Napoleon.  The papal apartments were  luxuriously  refurbished – in spite of, and contrary to the Pope’s express wishes, and arrangements were made for a papal ‘Gala Mass’ with great pomp and splendour, to be celebrated  in the Cathedral, attended by religious, civil, and military dignitaries.  The Pope refused to cooperate, explaining that if a Consistory were called, it would have to be with cardinals of his own choosing, and that it should be held in Rome.  With regard to the refurbishing of his quarters, he considered it inappropriate that he should be living in luxury whilst the Church  everywhere was suffering so much.

The Pope was repeatedly urged by Chabrol, the Prefect of Montenotte (which included Savona),  to comply with Napoleon’s wishes, and specifically  to agree the incorporation of Rome and the Papal States into the French Empire, with the Pope as chaplain to the Emperor, and residing in France. Pope Pius was not interested.

 
                                    ST.PETER (C. Tura 1474)

In January 1810,  a frustrated and angry Napoleon, determined to settle the affairs of Rome and to ensure that there was no restoration of the Temporal Power of the Papacy, adopted more aggressive tactics, with his men entering the offices of the ecclesiastical tribunals and seizing the archives, also invading the papal Treasury and removing priceless vestments, altar vessels and works of sacred art, all of which were to be sent to Paris. Even the papal seals and the ‘Fisherman’s Ring’- with which Papal Bulls were authenticated, were taken. All the cardinals, bar one - elderly and infirm, were sent to France, together with the heads of Religious Orders and Chief Officers of the Congregations and Departments of State. Napoleon  intended  to transfer the papacy to France, preferably to Paris or possibly Avignon. He  then issued the Imperial decree (Feb 1810)  confirming that Rome and the Papal States had been incorporated into the French Empire, with ‘Rome now the second city of the Empire’. The Pope only learned of this from the newspaper ‘Moniteur’.

 At about this time,  Napoleon’s marriage to Josephine was annulled, and he ‘married’ Marie Louise, Archduchess of Austria, daughter of the Emperor Francis. Due to questionable canonical process,  the annulment was not recognised by the Pope nor by many senior clerics and many of the clergy, who subsequently refused to attend  the ‘wedding’.  As a result  thirteen Cardinals plus Consalvi,  were arrested and later banished.


         PAPAL TIARA - A GIFT TO P.PIUS VII FROM NAPOLEON.        (IRONICALLY, THE  EMERALD, THE PRINCIPAL JEWEL IN THE TIARA,WAS  EXACTED  FROM P. PIUS VI - REMOVED FROM THE TRIPLE CROWN AT THE VATICAN - AS PART OF THE INDEMNITY AT THE TREATY OF TOLENTINO 1797)

The Austrian diplomat Lebzeltern, who visited the Pope about this time, found him “considerably aged, but in good health, tranquil and serene. There is not the least harshness in his manner of speaking, even when touching on questions most displeasing to him. He is very firm regarding questions upon which he could never give way-------. Not a single word comes from him concerning those who have usurped his sovereignty. What weighs most on him is Pacca’s imprisonment, the dispersion of his ministers and cardinals, and the banishment of some of these,  together with bishops abiding by his instructions.” Lebzeltern further reported that the Pope felt no resentment concerning his treatment by Napoleon, but only love and pity for him. “None, more than we, desire the Emperor’s happiness. He is a prince of many fine qualities. Would to Heaven he could see where his true interests lie …”

                               ST.PETER'S,  ROME

Napoleon now sought in earnest to justify his liquidation of the Pope’s temporal power, cultivating French sympathies by accusing previous Popes particularly Gregory VII, Boniface VIII, Julius II, and Innocent XI, of hostility to the French nation. In Rome he set up a ‘Consulta’ group of prominent citizens who would be encouraged to vent their grievances. When large numbers of the clergy, encouraged by the Pope in secret letters,  refused to swear allegiance to the new regime, Napoleon retaliated by depriving them of their living and banishing them, with the Sees of uncooperative bishops being abolished.

 Napoleon had increasing problems with the ever-growing number of vacant sees, for the Pope maintained his passive resistance by refusing to institute to their Sees those bishops nominated by him. The Emperor then considered setting up a National Council, or failing this, a General Council, to devise a solution to the problem. He also arranged, with the unlikely aid of his ‘new father-in-law’, Emperor Francis of Austria, for the diplomat Lebzeltern to make a further visit to the Pope, to seek a solution to the problem ‘in the interest of the Church’,

CHRIST HANDING THE KEYS TO PETER   (Perugino1481)

The Pope received Lebzeltern cordially, believing that the purpose of his visit was to achieve peace in Europe. Having listened to his proposals, Pius insisted that:-
 1) the Emperor Francis must guarantee any settlement,
 2) that he himself be returned to Rome (but not necessarily as temporal ruler)
3) that he should have his counsellors restored to him
4) that Napoleon should give clear evidence of a change of heart.

He intimated that if these conditions were accepted, the excommunication previously imposed, might be lifted.   Lebzeltern was satisfied with this, but Napoleon was not.

Napoleon now decided that he would have his Episcopal nominees elected by the Cathedral Chapters as ‘Administrators Capitular’, thus enabling them to carry out their duties even if they could not take their titles. The Pope heard of this plan and sent a secret letter to the Vicar Capitular of Paris, roundly condemning the plan. Unfortunately the letter was intercepted by Napoleon’s agents, resulting in imprisonment for the Vicar Capitular and a mass round-up of all sympathetic clergy, Without their leaders the remaining clergy weakened, agreeing in principle to  Napoleon's plan, although this on its own, would still not satisfactorily solve the problem.

 Hence in 1811, yet another Ecclesiastical Committee recommended that the investiture problem should be the responsibility of a National Council, who would propose that 'failing investiture by the Pope, after 6 months the bishops nominated by the Emperor, should be instituted to their Sees by the Metropolitan of the Province'.  Napoleon then arranged for three acceptable bishops  to visit the Pope in Savona, taking with them letters signed by ten cardinals, two archbishops, and seven bishops- Italian and Spanish as well as French, which pleaded with him ‘to make all possible sacrifices’ for the sake of the peace of the Church. It seemed that this would succeed, for the Pope agreed ‘in principle’ to the six months proposal, which was then embodied in a draft and carried off very promptly by the small delegation before the Pope could change his mind, but also before he had signed it.


After they  left,  the Pope  gave further thought to what had transpired, and  realised his mistake in allowing himself  to discuss such matters without the guidance and advice of his own counsellors. He also realised that he had  provisionally agreed, albeit only verbally, to yield an important part of the traditional authority of the papacy, namely the investiture of the bishops of the Church. Immediately he sent word by messenger to the returning delegation to warn them that he had promised nothing, and that he repented, as a folly, having even considered as a basis for discussion, the document they had drawn up.  Napoleon ignored this disclaimer, and at the National Council which opened in June, 1811, he blandly stated that he had the Pope’s agreement on the vital issue which they were called to discuss.

                               ST.PETER (P.Brandl 1724)

There were no less than six cardinals and eighty-nine bishops present - forty-two of them from Italy. The Emperor was attempting to settle a major matter of authority in the Western Church without the active assistance of the Pope. In effect he was falling back on the Gallican theory that a Council was superior to the Pope. He was in for a rude shock, for what many of the French clergy had accepted at the time of the Civil Constitution, hardly any would accept now. After an opening address by Napoleon’s minister, Bigot, in which he attacked the ‘iniquities’ of Pius VII and flattered those clergy present,  a sermon from the Bishop of Troyes,  based on Bossuet’s famous ‘Discourse on the Unity of the Church’ of 1682,  declared that they would ‘never detach themselves from that first link in the chain, without which all the others would fall away, and would leave nothing to be seen, save confusion, anarchy, and ruin.’ Each bishop then took the oath, customary at the inauguration of Councils,  ‘I recognise the Holy Church, Catholic and Roman, Apostolic and Roman, as mother and mistress of all the Churches. I promise and I swear true obedience to the supreme Roman Pontiff, successor of Saint Peter, prince of the apostles and vicar of Jesus Christ.’

A furious Napoleon denounced the Bishops as traitors for having taken an oath to two sovereigns 'who were at enmity with one another', and demanded a speedy settlement on  the matter for which the Council had been called, emphasising that he already had the Pope’s approval. The Bishops understandably doubted this, and insisted that the Council could register no valid decree without the consent of the Pope, obtained from him by a deputation from the Council, and bearing his signature.

          POPE PIUS VII aged 77yrs     (T.Lawrence 1819)

Napoleon was enraged, immediately dismissing the Council and casting into prison the three bishops he considered to be the ringleaders. His next step was to obtain from each of  those bishops still in Paris, a personal agreement to his proposals. Believing that a personal statement would carry little or no weight for committing the Church over the head of the Pope, and also intimidated by Napoleon, a total of eighty-five signatures were obtained. The Council was then hastily re-convened, and a collective agreement on the basis of the individual agreements already obtained, was achieved, with the proviso from the bishops that the agreement must be approved by the Pope.

A further delegation was then sent to Savona, where they  convinced the Pope that Napoleon sincerely wished for a just settlement, reinforcing this with many messages of respect and goodwill from cardinals and clergy. Although the Pope was persuaded to agree to Napoleon's request for 'Metropolitan Investitures in the event of a six months delay', he  insisted that the Paris Council was not a valid Council, and he accordingly re-wrote the decree as one emanating from himself, as Supreme Pontiff,  couching it in terms which excluded the bishops of the Papal States from being reckoned amongst those who could be invested by the Metropolitans. Although  the deputation was both surprised and delighted by his compliance,  Napoleon still refused to accept it, insisting that the Papal States must be included. Pope Pius would not budge on this point, and neither would Napoleon, who was obsessed with asserting his authority over the papacy in matters spiritual as well as temporal. Not even over the hierarchy of the Patrimony of St Peter would he allow the Pope to have final authority. Thus effectively Napoleon had discarded the opportunity of a religious settlement which might have done much to strengthen his hold upon the Mediterranean countries.

                       ST. PETER  (P.Besenzi  17th c.)

Ironically, Pius’ refusal to let the Emperor re-organize religion in Rome and central Italy,  had prevented him from issuing a brief which would have surrendered the papal position on a point of fundamental importance everywhere, namely papal investiture of bishops with their spiritual authority.  Popes had been accused before of sacrificing the true interests of the Church to those of the Papal States, but paradoxically on this occasion, the Pope’s concern for the Papal States had resulted in safeguarding the unique religious authority of the Papacy..

Napoleon however, did not give up. He was still militarily and politically powerful,  still confident and ambitious. He believed that it would greatly strengthen his bargaining  position if he arranged for the Pope to be transferred to France.  The trials and sufferings of Pope Pius VII were not yet over.
                                                                                                                                    (to be continued)

 Acknowledgement - 'Revolution and Papacy' by E Hales.(publisher Hanover House 1960).

'The Last Four Sorrows' of Our Lady' - Charles Journet

  'The Last Four Sorrows of Our Lady' Charles Journet                          Fourth Sorrow   This was Mary’s sufferings ...