Tuesday, 9 October 2012

The Orthodox Barber by G.K.Chesterton


The following sketch was one of many written by G.K. Chesterton in the early 1900’s, and published in the ‘Daily News’ national newspaper. They were subsequently printed in book form by Sheed and Ward, New York, in 1955, under the title ‘Tremendous Trifles’.
 
 
                Gilbert Keith (G.K.) Chesterton (1874 - 1936)
 
When reading this particular article, written more than one hundred years ago, it is interesting to note how the author’s observations  apply equally to today’s world as it did then.  I don't only mean this in the context of his obvious affection, respect, and understanding of people generally, but also the spiritual realities  which he recognises in man’s fallen nature:- 
             
       “ but every now and then men jump up with the new something or other, and say that everything can be had without sacrifice, that bad is good if you are only enlightened, and that there is no real difference between being shaved and not being shaved.  The difference, they say, is only a difference of degree; everything is evolutionary and relative.”  
         
       Sounds rather familiar -  but do read for yourself!
 
                                 The Orthodox Barber

Those thinkers who cannot believe in any gods often assert that the love of humanity would be in itself sufficient for them; and so perhaps it would, if they had it. There is a very real thing which may be called the love of humanity; in our time it exists almost entirely among what are called uneducated people; and it does not exist at all among the people who talk about it.
       

       A positive pleasure in being in the presence of any other human being is chiefly remarkable, for instance, in the masses on Bank Holiday; that is why they are so much nearer Heaven  (despite appearances) than any other part of our population.
       

       I remember seeing a crowd of factory girls getting into an empty train at a wayside country station. There were about twenty of them; they all got into one carriage; and they left all the rest of the train entirely empty. That is the real love of humanity. That is the definite pleasure in the immediate proximity of one’s own kind. Only, this coarse, rank, real love of men seems to be entirely lacking in those who propose the love of humanity as a substitute for all other love; honourable, rationalistic idealists.
       

       I can well remember the explosion of human joy which marked the sudden starting of that train; all the factory girls who could not find seats  (and they must have been the majority),  relieving their feelings by jumping up and down.       
      
       Now I have never seen any rationalistic idealists do this. I have never seen twenty modern philosophers crowd into one third-class carriage for the mere pleasure of being together. I have never seen twenty Mr. McCabes  all  in one carriage and all jumping up and down.
 
       Some people express a fear that vulgar trippers will overrun all beautiful places, such as Hampstead or Burnham Beeches. But their fear is unreasonable; because trippers always prefer to trip together; they pack as close as they can; they have a suffocating passion of philanthropy
 

 
Saint Elias Ardounis - 'Orthodox' Patron Saint of Barbers
 
      But among the minor and milder aspects of the same principle, I have no hesitation in placing the problem of the colloquial barber.  Before any modern man talks with authority about loving men, I insist (I insist with violence) that he shall always be very much pleased when his barber tries to talk to him.  His barber is humanity: let him love that. If he is not pleased at this, I will not accept any substitute in the way of interest in the Congo or in the future of Japan.  If a man cannot love his barber whom he has seen, how shall he love the Japanese whom he has not seen?
 

      It is urged against the barber that he begins by talking about the weather; so do all dukes and diplomatists, only that they talk about it with ostentatious fatigue and indifference, whereas the barber talks about it with an astonishing, nay incredible, freshness of interest. It is objected to him that he tells people that they are going bald. That is to say, his very virtues are cast up against him; he is blamed because, being a specialist, he is a sincere specialist, and because, being a tradesman, he is not entirely a slave. But the only proof of such things is by example; therefore I will prove the
excellence of the conversation of barbers by a specific case.       
      
       Lest anyone should accuse me of attempting to prove it by fictitious means, I beg to say quite seriously that though I forget the exact language employed, the following conversation between me and a human (I trust) living barber, really took place a few days ago.
 


                            Mediaeval barber's shop

       I had been invited to some ‘At Home’ to meet the Colonial Premiers, and lest I should be mistaken for some partly reformed bush-ranger out of the interior of Australia, I went into a shop in the Strand to get shaved.
      
       While I was undergoing the torture,  the man said to me:    
      “There seems to be a lot in the papers about this new shaving, sir. It seems you can shave yourself with anything – with a stick or a stone or a pole or a poker” (here I began for the first time to detect a sarcastic intonation) “or a shovel or a –".
       Here he hesitated for a word, and I, although I knew nothing about the matter, helped him out with suggestions in the same rhetorical vein.
       “Or a button-hook,” I said, “or a blunderbuss or a battering ram or a piston- rod –“
        He resumed, refreshed with this assistance, “Or a curtain rod or a candle-stick, or
a –“
       “Cow-catcher,” I suggested eagerly, and we continued in this ecstatic duet for some time.

       Then I asked him what it was all about, and he told me. He explained the thing eloquently and at length.
 

      “The funny part of it is,” he said, “that the thing isn’t new at all. It’s been talked about ever since I was a boy, and long before.  There is always the notion that the razor might be done without somehow. But none of those schemes ever came to anything; and I don’t believe myself that this will.”
 

      “Why, as to that,” I said, rising slowly from the chair and trying to put on my coat inside out, “I don’t know how it may be in the case of you and your new shaving. Shaving with all respect to you, is a trivial and materialistic thing, and in such things startling inventions are sometimes made.        
      
       But what you say reminds me in some dark and dreamy  fashion of something else.  I recall it especially when you tell me with such evident experience and sincerity, that the new shaving is not really new. 
      
       My friend, the human race is always trying this dodge of making everything entirely easy; but the difficulty which it shifts off one thing it shifts on to another.  If one man has not the toil of preparing a man’s chin, I suppose that some other man has the toil of preparing something very curious to put on a man’s chin. 
      
       It would be nice if we could be shaved without troubling anybody.  It would be nicer still if we could go unshaved without annoying anybody –
                

    ‘But, O wise friend, chief Barber of the Strand, Brother, nor you nor I have made the world.’


Whoever made it, Who is wiser, and we hope better than we, made it under strange limitations, and with painful conditions of pleasure."
            

       “In the first and darkest of its books, it is fiercely written that a man shall not eat his cake and have it; and though all men talked until the stars were old, it would still be true that a man who had shaved had lost his beard, and that a man who had lost his razor could not shave with it.           
       
       But every now and then men jump up with the new something or other and say that everything can be had without sacrifice, that bad is good if you are only enlightened, and that there is no real difference between being shaved and not being shaved. "
 
       "The difference, they say, is only a difference of degree; everything is evolutionary and relative. Shavedness is immanent in man. Every ten-penny nail is a Potential Razor.  The superstitious people of the past (they say), believed that a lot of black bristles standing out at right angles to one’s face was a positive affair.  But the higher criticism teaches us better.  Bristles are merely negative. They are a Shadow where Shaving should be."
 
       “Well, it all goes on, and I suppose it all means something.  But a baby is the Kingdom of God, and if you try to kiss a baby he will know whether you are shaved or not.  Perhaps I am mixing up being shaved and being saved; my democratic sympathies have always led me to drop my ‘h’s.’ In another moment I may suggest that goats represent the lost because goats have long beards. This is growing altogether too allegorical."
 

“Nevertheless,” I added, as I paid the bill, “I have really been profoundly interested in what you told me about the New Shaving.  Have you ever heard of a thing called the New Theology?” 
 
He smiled and said that he had not.
               

                              *********************



'When devotion towards Mary begins in a soul, it produces the same effect that the birth of this most holy Virgin produced in the world. It puts an end to the night of sin, and leads the soul into the path of virtue'
(Thoughts from St Alphonsus de Liguori)
 


Monday, 3 September 2012

SNP Cabinet Minister - "Well they've done it in Portugal and the sky's not fallen in"



Last Friday, the Scottish Cabinet held a public meeting  in Kirkwall, Orkney. The meeting was chaired by the Deputy First Minister, Nicola Sturgeon, in the absence of the First Minister Alex Salmond, and had been arranged by the Scottish SNP government,  to  give  members of the public an opportunity to put  any questions they wished. 

 I was impressed with both the  meeting itself, and the fact that members of the public were able to speak personally with Ministers after the meeting had ended.

My  reason for attending was to voice opposition to the ‘same-sex marriage’ legislation, which the  government  plans to bulldoze onto the statute books, in spite of strong and widespread  opposition from the Catholic Church, the Orthodox Church, many Evangelical and Protestant Churches, many in the Church of Scotland , and tens, if not hundreds of thousands, of individuals of other faiths or none.

The meeting , which lasted from 12.30p.m. to 2 p.m., was scrupulously fair in that  open questions were invited  from any person present. I was able to raise  a question concerning mis-representation by the SNP government concerning the percentage of Scottish residents opposed to ‘same-sex ‘  marriage as revealed by the numbers who actively voiced their opposition in writing and by ‘petition’  to the government; and the fact that these  views had been   ignored and over-ruled by the SNP government  in spite of earlier  assurances that this would not happen.  Another question was put by a lady teacher who raised the question of future criminal liability, if in her capacity as a teacher, she refused to teach children about same-sex marriage.

Nicola  Sturgeon replied to both my question and that of the teacher, or rather I should say that she appeared to reply but what she said was not the answer to my question, it was rather the same official line that the SNP politicians have been posting all the time, namely that fairness and equality to everyone would be enshrined in the proposed legislation, and the government would ensure that religious organisations would not be under any threat to act against their faith/conscience in any way!

Once the Minister had replied to a question it was not possible to put any further questions, so the final word was always with them! 
 
A young man in the audience demanded that  the government  take appropriate action  to protect young people of homosexual inclination, whom he alleged, were continually bullied and threatened , particularly in faith schools,  making their lives a misery! He spoke  loudly, aggressively, and accusingly,  which I suspect did not endear him  to the Cabinet.  He received noticeably short thrift from the appropriate Minister, being reminded that there was already adequate legislation in place to protect minority groups, and the Minister made a point of endorsing the high standards set by Roman Catholic schools in Scotland to protect all their students against bullying and hate crime.
 
After the meeting we were fortunate to be able  to talk briefly to Fiona Hyslop,  Cabinet Secretary for Culture and External Affairs,  also to the Deputy First Minister,  Nicola Sturgeon. 

Both were charming as one would expect from eminent politicians, and both seemed happy to listen.  The answer I received from Fiona Hyslop deserves to be saved for posterity, and rather sums up the mind-set of  politicians who refuse to face reality,  shutting their minds to the serious implications  of legalising so-called 'same-sex marriage'.  
 
Fiona’s reply was simply, “Well they’ve done it in Portugal , and the sky’s not fallen in!”
 
I must admit that this reply took me by surprise, and my undoubtedly feeble riposte was not  in the same league! 

I then had a brief opportunity to speak to  Nicola Sturgeon, repeating  my fears  regarding the proposed legislation and emphasising that I was but one of a huge number  of people holding these views.  Again the Minister reeled off the party line, viz. protecting religious freedom, need for full equality, etc. etc.
 
My friend Michelle who also attended the meeting, was able to make  some telling  points to both Fiona Hyslop and Nicola  Sturgeon , and I strongly recommend her excellent post:-
 
http://catholicorkney.blogspot.co.uk/2012/08/the-scottish-cabinet-open-discussion.html........  please read it, she writes from the heart!  

We have it from good authority viz. the Christian Institute,  that the battle against ‘same-sex marriage' legislation can be won. There are many potential pitfalls for this proposed legislation, and for God's sake and for the sake of the dignity and humanity of mankind, made in God's image, the fight must go on.
 
Grateful thanks to Cardinal O’Brien for his leadership, courage, and unequivocal condemnation of this proposed legislation. The Catholics of Scotland respect this outspoken Shepherd, as I’m sure do many others of different faiths and none. As the Cardinal said in his recent letter to Catholic churches, it is necessary to speak out loudly,  clearly,  and fearlessly against this evil legislation. 
 
We know that with  God’s help  all things are possible, without it we can do nothing.

       ************************************
 
Since the ‘Canonical Erection’ of the Sons of the Most Holy Redeemer (F.SS.R) community on the 15th August by  the Bishop of Aberdeen, it has been a pretty busy last two weeks here in Stronsay.

As I’m sure everyone knows by now, His Lordship Dom Hugh Gilbert OSB  Bishop of Aberdeen, accompanied by Very Rev Dom Benedict Hardy  OSB , Prior of Pluscarden Abbey, and Very Rev  Cuthbert Madden OSB, Abbot of Ampleforth Abbey, stayed  at Golgotha Monastery, Papa Stronsay, the home of the F.SS.R , during the week of the 20th August.  On the 22nd  Bishop  Hugh  officiated at the 'Public Profession of Vows' by Fr Michael Mary  (Superior ) ,Fr Anthony Mary (Rector),  Br Yusef Marie , Br Jean Marie , Br Magdala Maria, Br Martin Mary, Br Nicodemus Mary,  and Br Gerardo Marie . 

Absent  were Br Paul Mary , Br Dominic Mary , Br Xavier Marie, all  currently in Christchurch, New Zealand, and Br Alfonso Maria  in the Phillipines. 
 
The occasion as befitted such a joyous and historic  event, was  one of solemn splendour, after all it is several hundred years since a new religious order of monks was founded in Scotland .

The ceremony lasted about two hours after which the Bishop, priests, brothers and congregation , all retired to St Magnus house adjoining the Chapel, for  delicious  refreshments and a most convivial evening.
 
I must say how beautiful ‘Our Lady’s Chapel’ looked for this unique occasion. The altar top had been enlarged,thereby creating room for a beautiful new tabernacle to be put in place. This tabernacle, together with three magnificent statues, one of  the  Boy Jesus, one of St Anne and a young Our Lady, and one of St Joseph with the Child Jesus, had all been brought up to Stronsay a few days earlier by Fr Anthony, Brothers Yusef Marie  and Jean Marie,  from the Isle of Sheppey in Kent, where the monks lived prior to moving to Papa Stronsay. 

In Our Lady’s Chapel, a throne had been erected for the Bishop which would not have looked too out of place in a Cathedral, and the whole chapel was filled with flowers. It  looked truly magnificent!  There are some excellent photos of the occasion on the Transalpine Redemptorists blog-site ........
                    


                      Our Lady's Chapel, Stronsay.

                       
                        ******************************

On the Saturday 25th August in the evening, we had the annual bonfire on Papa Stronsay to which all the residents of Stronsay were invited. 

Happily the weather was kind, being dry and mild, with just a slight breeze, the bonfire was awe-inspiring, as usual, and the superb barbecue and generous selection of tasty  food and drink was  more than adequate.  The bonfire was lit by Brother Seelos who celebrated his 21st birthday that same week, and the occasion was a rare opportunity for many to meet and chat with the Fathers and Brothers of the Community.

We took the opportunity to visit their splendid greenhouse with its impressive display of nectarines, apples, grapes, strawberries, and other fruit and vegetables, and which included  two massive pumpkins, the pride and joy of Brother Jean Marie!

We were also shown the brand new  chicken-house, a luxury  home for the 'monastic' chickens, built very recently by the monks,  and I can truly say it is the most impressive chicken-house that I have ever seen! Solidly constructed of concrete blocks and wood, strengthened with metal sections, it is divided into three main compartments, dry and weather-proof, with access to an area of fenced open ground which itself will be opened-up for the chickens to roam free-range once they have become fully settled in their new home. The whole building was spotlessly clean with fresh greenery covering the floors. The chickens looked eminently comfortable and at home on their various roosting bars, and the whole place was  so  clean, dry, and sweet-smelling, that  I would have been quite content to sleep there if adverse weather conditions  had suddenly struck, preventing our return by boat to Stronsay! 
 
By the way, do look (and listen) at the blog-site of the Traditional Redemptorists for a  ‘mind-blowing’  version of the bonfire spectacle  ---  superb!!
    
             
               *********************************
 
Weather-wise, we on Stronsay might not have had a very good summer, but event wise it has been truly memorable, with innumerable graces and blessings from Almighty God.
 
May Our Lady of Aberdeen guide and protect the 'Sons of the Most Holy Redeemer' (F.SS.R) community, and may She cast Her protective mantle  over our Bishop and all priests. religious, and  faithful in our Diocese.

 

                Diocese of Aberdeen - Coat of Arms


        God bless our Holy Father, Pope Benedict XVI. 

Friday, 3 August 2012

'In the Steps of the Master' once more

 Herewith a few more extracts from  H.V.Morton’s  classic ‘In the Steps of the Master’, written  in the 1920s, in which he recounted his impressions and experiences whilst re-tracing the journeys of Our Lord Jesus Christ through the Holy Land.

                      ‘On the roads of Palestine, and on the hills, you see the good shepherd. He comes along at the head of his flock, generally carrying over his shoulders a lamb or an injured sheep.
He is a man burnt almost black by exposure to the sun. He wears the flowing Bedouin head-veil, the keffiyeh, bound with two black twisted cords known as the agaal.  Beneath his robes he often wears a sheepskin coat with the fleece turned next to the body.  He is one of the many characters who walk the roads of Palestine exactly as they must have done in the time of Our Lord.'
 


                                             Palestinian Shepherd

'A most remarkable thing is the sympathy that exists between him and his flock.  He never drives them as our own shepherds drive their sheep. He always walks at their head, leading them along the roads and over the hills to new pasture: and, as he goes, he sometimes talks to them in a loud sing-song voice, using a weird language unlike anything I have ever heard in my life. 

The first time I heard this sheep and goat language I was on the hills at the back of Jericho.  A goat-herd had descended into a valley and was mounting the slope of an opposite hill when, turning round, he saw his goats had remained behind to devour a rich patch of scrub.  Lifting his voice, he spoke to the goats in a language that Pan must have spoken on the mountains of Greece.  It was uncanny because there was nothing human about it.  The words were animal sounds arranged in a kind of order.  No sooner had he spoken than an answering bleat shivered over the herd, and one or two of the animals turned their heads in his direction. But they did not obey him. 

The goat-herd then called out one word and gave a laughing kind of whinny.  Immediately a goat with a bell around his neck stopped eating and, leaving the herd, trotted down the hill, across the valley and up the opposite slopes.  The man, accompanied by  this animal, walked on and disappeared round a ledge of rock. Very soon a panic spread among the herd. They forgot to eat. They looked up for the shepherd. He was not to be seen. They became conscious that the leader with the bell at his neck was no longer with them.  From the distance came the strange laughing call of the shepherd, and at the sound of it the entire herd stampeded into the hollow and leapt up the hill after him.
 

I would like to know what an English sheep-dog would make of the Palestine sheep, because our principle of droving is something that neither Arab shepherds nor their sheep-dogs understand.  It is all done by word of mouth, and the sheep follow their shepherds like dogs.  The Arab sheep-dog is used therefore not to drive sheep but to protect them against thieves and wild animals.
 

Early one morning I saw an extraordinary sight not far from Bethlehem. Two shepherds had evidently spent the night with their flocks in a cave. The sheep were all mixed together and the time had come for the shepherds to go in different directions. One of the shepherds stood some distance from the sheep and began to call. First one, then another, then four or five animals ran towards him; and so on until he had counted his whole flock.'
 

'More interesting than the sight of this was the knowledge that Jesus must have seen exactly the same sight and described it in His own words:
 

             “He calleth his own sheep by name, and leadeth them out. And when he putteth forth his own sheep, he goeth before them, and the sheep follow him: for they know his voice. And a stranger they will not follow, but will flee from him: for they know not the voice of strangers.  This parable spake Jesus unto them ........ I am the good shepherd, and know my sheep and am known of mine” '


'No animal mentioned in the Bible can compare in symbolical interest with the sheep. I believe it is mentioned over five-hundred times.  And you cannot go very far along the roads of Palestine without encountering the figure who, staff in hand, symbolises the love and compassion of Jesus Christ.’
                         
              ************

Having visited the ruins of the synagogue of Capernaum, the author wrote:-
 


             Ruins of the Synagogue at Capernaum - early 1900s

‘One sits in the ruin of this building watching the blue lake, trying hard to build up a picture of Jesus as He appeared to His contemporaries.  The traditional bare-headed Jesus of Christian art cannot be correct. Perhaps Dr Stapfer has drawn a more authentic portrait in his ‘Palestine in the time of Christ’;
 

“He had neither the fine linen nor the sumptuous raiment of those who live in kings’ houses,” he wrote, “neither had he a long flowing robe like the scribes and Pharisees. Upon His head He must have worn the turban, the national head-gear, used alike by rich and poor.  Painters make a mistake when they represent Christ bare-headed. As we have said, with everyone the head was covered. The turban He wore was probably white. It was fastened under the chin by a cord, and at the side fell down to the shoulders and over the tunic. Under His turban He wore His hair rather long and His beard uncut. His tunic, and underneath vesture, was of one piece without seam; it was therefore of some value (John xix. 23), and had probably been given Him by one of those women who ‘ministered to Him of their substance.’ Over this He wore the talith, loose and flowing.  The mantle was not white, for we are told it became white during the Transfiguration. It was not red, for that was only the military colour. It is possible it was blue, for blue was then very common, or it may have been simply white with brown stripes. In any case Jesus had at the four corners of this mantle, the Ciccith, the blue or white fringes of which we have just spoken. He wore sandals on His feet, as we learn from John the Baptist; and when He was travelling, going from place to place, He doubtless wore a girdle around the loins and carried a stick in His hand ...” '
            
        

           Jesus casting out devil  (Mathew Ch 17 v.14-20)

                                  ***************
 

The author travelled to Beirut where he stayed in an hotel immediately overlooking St George’s Bay. Of his visit there he wrote:- 
            ‘I began to think of St George, that sadly libelled Saint, who was the patron of Beirut centuries before we in England placed his cross on our banners.  I think Calvin began the belittlement of St George, but Gibbon certainly started the libel. It is a curious thing that thousands of Englishman who have not read the ‘Decline and Fall’ will tell you that St George was a villainous army contractor at Cappadocia. He was nothing of the kind. Gibbon, very strangely for a man of such meticulous accuracy, confused two men, or rather assumed that George of Laodicea, who was murdered in the reign of Julian and whose body was flung into the sea, was the Christian soldier who was martyred under Diocletian.  Gibbon’s George was indeed a bad character, a man who, as Gregory Nazianzen said, would ‘sell himself for a cake’. He became Arian archbishop of Alexandria and the retribution which overtook him must have been of a singularly brutal character, because the Emperor Julian wrote a letter of remonstrance, in which he said, “the people actually tore a man to pieces, as if they had been dogs." 

'The saint however, was a Roman officer of high standing who suffered death rather than countenance a Christian persecution ordered by Diocletian. I remember discussing him with Sir E A Wallis Budge, whose book ‘St George of Lydda’ should be read by everyone interested in the saint. Sir Ernest believed that his martyrdom might have occurred as early as 200 AD, although the accepted date is 303 AD. The traditions of East and West agree that after St George was martyred in Nicomedia, a town about forty miles east of Constantinople, his body was brought to Lydda – now Ludd, near Jaffa, for burial.
 

The veneration he inspired among the members of the early Church was so great that hundreds of extravagant legends gathered round his name, among them the story of the Dragon, which many scholars regard as a pagan myth grafted to the Christian tree. Many an agnostic points to the ridiculous stories about saints and martyrs to prove the credulity of the early Church.  It is not generally realised that many of these stories were recognised as fiction and as nothing else. Pope Gelasius made war on such devout fictions at the Council of ‘Seventy-two  Bishops’ in Rome in 494 AD, when he ordered the faithful to discontinue the reading of such stories for the reason that they called down ridicule on the Christian Faith. Among the stories banned were those about St George.'


      St George dragged through the streets prior to martyrdom - (Bernardo Martorell 15th century)

'When the Crusaders came marching along the coast road towards which I was looking, they had already encountered St George at the very gates of the East, for the Bosphorous was called ‘the Arm of St George’.  Everywhere they went they heard stories of the Saint’s courage and holiness. In time they came to believe that he was riding beside them. Stories in no way more remarkable than that of the 'Angels of Mons', in which thousands of people believed in 1914, began to spread when the Crusaders were in trouble. A mysterious white horseman with a red cross emblazoned on his sur-coat was seen helping the cause of Christ, first at Antioch and later in many desperate battles.'


                                          Flag of St George

'The Crusaders, returning home to England, told stories of the saint and of his miraculous interventions. It was, therefore, natural that Richard should have restored the Church of St George at Lydda, should have used the name of St George for the English battle-cry, and should have returned from the Holy Land with a patron Saint who was recognised in the East and in the West as the perfect Christian soldier.'
 

Ack. 'In the Steps of the Master' by H.V.Morton. First published by Rich and Cowan Ltd., London, 1934.                           
                       

Sunday, 1 July 2012

'In the Steps of the Master' - an indelible read.

 ‘In the Steps of the Master’ by H.V.Morton,  recounts  the author’s  travels in the Holy Land - ‘on a search after the footsteps of Jesus, the disciples and the prophets’.. ...  ‘I have attempted to put down in this book the thoughts that come to a man as he travels through Palestine with the New Testament in his hands.’




                             Church of the Nativity, Bethlehem


 Published in 1934 by Rich and Cowan Ltd. London, this is a beautifully written book, easy to read and full of interesting and informative detail of places and people, with 24 photographic plates, and the whole tied-in to the New Testament account of Our Lord’s public life.
I am only part of the way through the book, but two items of particular interest – at least to me, stay in my mind. The first relates to  Christ’s birthplace; and the second to  the parable of the woman seeking the coin which she had lost.


Jesus was born in a stable at Bethlehem, and our Christmas cards and carols usually  portray  this from a European perspective.  However, H.V.Morton writes:-
                    
                      ‘There are a number of old houses in Bethlehem built over caves in the limestone rock. These caves are exactly the same as the sacred grotto under the High Altar of the Church of the Nativity, and they are probably as ancient.  No one who has seen these houses can doubt that Jesus was born in one of them, and not in the stable of European tradition.'


The High Altar in the Church of the Nativity, Bethlehem (1833) - from a painting by Maxim Vorobiev (1787-1855) Immediately below the altar is the cave in which traditionally Our Lord was born.


'I suppose the idea that Christ was born in a stable was suggested by St Luke’s use of the word ‘manger’.  To the Western mind this word presupposes a stable or a barn, or some outbuilding separate from the house and used as a shelter for animals. But there is nothing in St Luke to justify this.


These primitive houses in Bethlehem gave me an entirely new idea of the scene of the Nativity. They are one-room houses built over caves. Whether these caves are natural or artificial I do not know: they are level with the road, but the room above them is reached by a flight of stone steps, perhaps fifteen or twenty. The caves are used to this day as stables for the animals, which enter from the road level. There are in most of them, a stone trough or manger, cut from the rock, and iron rings to which the animals are tied during the night. The family occupy the upper chamber, separated only by the thickness of the rock floor from the cave in which the animals sleep.'






   Interior of the Church of the Nativity, Bethlehem, showing the site of the 4th century mosaic flooring dating from the time of Constantine, discovered in 1934 beneath the present floor.


'Now if Joseph and Mary had visited the ‘Inn’ at Bethlehem and found it full, there would have been no stable for them to go to, because the ‘Inns’ or ‘khans’, in the time of Christ were merely open spaces surrounded by a high wall and a colonnade under whose arches were rooms for the travellers. The animals were not stabled in the European sense, but were gathered together in the centre of the enclosure. The Greek word katalyma used by St Luke, and translated as ‘Inn’, would be more exactly rendered as ‘guest chamber’.'






          Detail of 4th century mosaic flooring (see above) -  Byzantine decorative style


'Therefore I believe we must imagine the Nativity to have taken place in one of these old cave-houses of Bethlehem. The guest-chamber, or upper room, which it was the Jewish custom to offer to travelling Jews, was already evidently occupied, and therefore the host did his best by offering to the Holy Family shelter in the downstairs room, or cave.


It is interesting in this connection to remember that the earliest tradition in the Church was that Jesus was born not in a stable or an inn, but in a cave.  Justin Martyr, who was born about 100 A.D, repeats a tradition current in his time that, as Joseph had no place in which to lodge in Bethlehem, he discovered a cave nearby. But even before Justin’s time it seems that the cave below the Church of the Nativity was venerated as the scene of Christ’s birth.  It is not unreasonable to assume that the caverns below this church were once above ground and formed the bottom storeys, or basements, of inhabited houses.'




The Grotto of the Nativity, an underground cave located beneath the basilica, enshrines the site where Jesus is said to have been born. The exact spot is marked beneath an altar by a 14-pointed silver star set into the marble floor and surrounded by silver lamps.


St Mathew, describing the birth of Jesus, says, “And when they were come into the house, they saw the young Child with Mary His mother; and fell down and worshipped Him.”     
                                               **************************


Married women wear a znekb or chain, and a high Bethlehem head-dress, with a flowing white veil. The veil is held in position by a small fez held upright on the head by two cords which tie beneath the chin. All round this little fez are sewn row upon row of coins. The znekb hangs from the head-dress and contains ten coins with a central pendant. Those coins represent a bride’s dowry, and it is probable that this was in Our Lord’s mind when He spoke of the parable of the lost coin. ‘What woman having ten pieces of silver, if she lose one piece, doth not light a candle, and sweep the house, and seek diligently until she finds it?’




              Three Bethlehem women, two wearing high head-dress         


Most people attribute this description as a tribute to the carefulness of women, but there is more to it. In Jewish times ten drachmae, or ten pieces of silver, were sewn on the head-dress of a married woman, and to lose one of them was a reflection on her carefulness or lack of it, and possibly on her wifely respect for her husband. It may also have given rise to that same superstitious fear which the loss of a wedding ring will bring to a modern wife.’
 
We know that  this parable reflects Our Lord’s love for those souls who have strayed from Him, and the ends to which He would go to find them and bring them back to Himself. The message is similar in sentiment to the parable of the ‘Good Shepherd’, prepared to go to any lengths even to lay down his life for his sheep, rather than lose them.              


                                            *****************************


The following passage is taken from 'The Way to Converse Continually and Familiarly with God'  by St Alphonsus Maria de Liguori.


‘The holy man Job was struck with astonishment at seeing God so intent on promoting man’s happiness, that He seemed to desire nothing more ardently than to love man, and that man should love Him in return; hence, speaking to Our Lord, he exclaims: What is man that Thou shouldst magnify him? Why dost Thou set Thy heart upon him?  (Job7:17)


'From this we see that it is a mistake to think that great confidence and familiarity in treating with God is want of reverence to His infinite Majesty.  You ought, indeed, devout soul, to revere God in all humility, and to abase yourself before Him, when you call to mind your ingratitude, and the outrages which in the past you have committed against Him. This however, should not hinder you from treating Him with the most tender love and greater confidence.


He is Infinite Majesty; but at the same time He is Infinite Goodness, Infinite Love.  You have in God the supreme Lord; but you have also in Him the greatest lover that can be imagined. He does not look down on you with disdain, but is full of joy when you treat Him with that confidence, that freedom, and that tenderness which children use towards their mothers.


Behold how He invites us to present ourselves at His feet! Behold the caresses which He promises us: "You shall be carried at the breasts, and upon the knees they shall caress you.  As one whom the mother caresseth, so will I comfort you." (Isa.66:12-13) As a mother delights in taking her dear little child upon her knees, in caressing and feeding him, so does our good God delight in treating with like love and tenderness the souls whom He loves, who give themselves entirely to Him, and place all their confidence in His goodness.’


(St Alphonsus Maria De Liguori)


Copies of this devotional booklet are available from the Transalpine Redemptorists, Papa Stronsay, Orkney, KW172AR. (Link on my sidebar)

Tuesday, 15 May 2012

'Common Sense' - 'the man on a Clapham omnibus'



Photo coutesy of Robert Munster, London Bus Routes


This post is concerned with a scenario which  50 years ago, would have been dealt with on the basis of 'common sense', a characteristic defined broadly in English law as ' the attitude manifested by a man on a Clapham omnibus'.

                                                        *******
The 'Archbishop Cranmer' blog-site recently published a copy of an article on the C4M (Coalition for Marriage) website, which defended the legal definition of  marriage, i.e. the voluntary union for life of one man and one woman to the exclusion of all others.

The post exhibited a montage of wedding day photographs, showing bride and groom on their special day. Wonderful photographs of smiling and happy couples.

C4M

The tradition of wedding-day photographs has been around since the advent of photography, in fact I was looking at some very old wedding photographs of my own family, my parents and  relations, taken over 75 years ago,  processed and printed in sepia. I'm sure that there have been thousands of wedding photographs published on the internet over the years, including those of Royal weddings. There is nothing new about this.

Apparently the ASA (Advertising Standards Agency),  has received complaints that 'Cranmer's' post  is offensive and homophobic. To me, it is absolutely clear that this is not the case, and that any such accusation is illogical, unreasonable, and worthless. Let me say straight away that I deplore homophobia.

However the ASA, which has no statutory powers as such, and which I would like to believe exists for the protection and good of society, perhaps a somewhat naive belief, has now turned all its guns on Cranmer, with bully-boy threats reminiscent of the novel '1984' ,written by that prescient author George Orwell.

So why has the ASA decided that 'Cranmer', by publishing this simple photographic montage of traditional weddings, is in breach of the regulations?  The photographs are no different from those already mentioned.

Could it be that the fault lies elsewhere, perhaps the words "I do" offend in some inconceivable way? But why, for after all if same sex marriages were legalised, presumably those participating would expect to use the same words? The phrase "I do" is subjective, conveying in this instance the vow of faithfulness taken by the bride and groom to each other. Nothing remotely offensive or homophobic about that.

The post then informs viewers that 70% of people want the definition of marriage to remain as it is, and then invites others to sign the ongoing on-line Petition in support of this. Certain people might not like the ongoing on-line Petition, and they might  disagree with the percentage figure quoted, which in any event is not 'Cranmer's responsibility, but that does not make the article  offensive or homophobic, which it clearly is not.  (see N.B. below)

In fact these accusations could be levelled more accurately at the government, which is endeavouring to bulldoze a change in the legal definition of marriage, effectively cocking-a-snoop  at those millions of people who desire and respect traditional marriage. The UK is not yet a dictatorship, in spite of powerful forces seemingly working for this, and free expression- with limitations, is still allowed.

The government has no mandate to force same-sex marriage onto the statute books, and if they do, is this not tantamount to homophobic behaviour, for it is an insult to, and crassly dismissive of, the sensibilities of millions of Christians and 2000 years of Christian heritage on which, with  exceptions like the Abortion Act, our whole legal system is based?
Those who oppose same-sex marriage are not out on a limb, they are
not the extremists or the anarchists, they are the vast majority of ordinary people prepared to stand up for traditional  standards and freedom of speech, and to speak out against the tyranny of 'abuse of power' by the state and its minions.

Interestingly the ASA is a non-statutory body with no power to fine or take advertisers to court, but is subject in the final analysis, to the authority of the Minister for Media and Culture, the Rt. Hon. Jeremy Hunt MP.  He is also the Minister ultimately  responsible for deciding whether to allow abortion providers to advertise their services on television, and in spite of  widespread opposition, including an on-line petition with several thousand signatories, I believe that he has not yet over-ruled the original ASA approval.

Some months ago I wrote a letter to him concerning this matter,  and received neither reply nor acknowledgement. I was not impressed, and I seriously question  the judgement of the ASA, primarly on certain ethical matters, highlighted for me by this particular decision.
The Chairman of the ASA, is Lord Smith of Finsbury, who is also the vice-president of the Campaign for Homosexual Equality.

A few details from the ASA website:-
'The ASA is here to make sure all advertisements are legal, decent, honest and truthful.' 
'The ASA is wholly funded by advertisers through a levy on advertising spend, and is not government funded.'
'These levies are collected by two separate bodies, the Advertising Standards Board of Finance (Asbof) and the Broadcast Advertising Standards Board of Finance (Basbof).' 
 'Each year the ASA pitches to Asbof and Basbof for its funding for the following year. The separate funding mechanism ensures that the ASA does not know which advertisers choose to fund the system or the amount they
contribute.
 This means that the ASA can take on the most powerful multinational companies without worrying about next year’s subscriptions.'
'The ASA is never aware of how much any company contributes to the system.' 

                                                         Really?
To conclude with a rather obvious question,  why have the ASA picked on
the 'Archbishop Cranmer' website for their offensive, and not say, the 'Coalition for Marriage' organisation? I wonder if the answer is that poor old 'Cranmer' is a one-man band, whereas C4M has over 513,000 known supporters and probably at least as many again on the sidelines. It's nearly always the little man that government bullies go for, have you noticed?
                                       
                                              +++++++++++

I take the liberty of quoting from Neil Addison's  posting on this very matter, as follows:-       http://religionlaw.blogspot.co.uk/   

'I am posting simply in the name of Freedom, the freedom to express a point of view with which other may disagree because as Lord Justice Sedley put it so memorably in Redmond Bate v DPP ' :-
               "Free speech includes not only the inoffensive but the irritating, the contentious, the eccentric, the heretical, the unwelcome and the provocative provided it does not tend to provoke violence. Freedom only to speak inoffensively is not worth having."                          
                                                       ..... to which we can only say 'AMEN'. 

                                            



                                                           ++++++++++++++
N.B.   A word about the 70% findings for traditional marriage. The survey was conducted by the highly respected Com Res company:-

'ComRes works with many leading blue-chip corporations, campaign groups, political parties, public sector bodies and trade bodies. We also poll for media clients ranging from The Independent to the BBC and ITV News. ComRes is a member of the British Polling Council and Association for Qualitative Research and employs members of the Market Research Society'

http://www.comres.co.uk/

'A ComRes online poll for Catholic Voices released on 8 March asked two separate questions: first, whether respondents supported civil partnerships (59% said yes they did); and second, whether they believed marriage should remain as an exclusive commitment between a man and a woman (70% said it should).
16 This poll had a relatively large sample
(n=2,000).'http://c4m.org.uk/downloads/briefing.pdf
                                     +++++++++++++++++++++++++++++

 A link to the original post from the 'Archbishop Cranmer' blogsite:

'The Last Four Sorrows' of Our Lady' - Charles Journet

  'The Last Four Sorrows of Our Lady' Charles Journet                          Fourth Sorrow   This was Mary’s sufferings ...